Home Learn Investigations

Show cause letter: how to respond to allegations

A show cause letter is a letter from your employer that sets out allegations against you and asks you to explain, usually by a set date, why you should not be disciplined or dismissed. If you have received one, or any letter asking you to respond to allegations, you are at the most important point in the whole process. Your written response becomes the central document if this ends in a dismissal and a claim. This page covers what the letter is for, your rights, how long you have, and how to write the response.

Most people meet the employment law system after they have lost their job. If you are reading this while still employed, you are in a much better position than most, and there are things you can do now that cannot be done later.

Short answers

What is a show cause letter?

It is the step where your employer tells you what it says you did, and gives you a chance to answer before it decides what to do. It often follows a workplace investigation. It is not yet a decision, and it is not yet a dismissal.

How long do I have to respond?

Whatever the letter says, often only a few days. No law sets a fixed period. If you are later dismissed and can bring an unfair dismissal claim, the Fair Work Commission looks at whether you were given an opportunity to respond. If the time is too short, ask for more in writing before the date passes.

Can I bring a support person?

You can ask to bring one to any meeting about the allegations. Your employer does not have to offer one, but if you are later dismissed, the Fair Work Commission looks at whether your employer unreasonably refused your request. So ask, in writing.

Do I have to admit the allegations?

No. Admit only what is true. Deny what is not, and explain what actually happened. Where something did happen, accepting it honestly and giving the context is usually better than a denial you cannot sustain.

I am on sick or stress leave. Can they still do this?

Being on leave does not by itself stop the process, but it is a good reason to ask for more time, with a medical certificate. The law also stops an employer dismissing you because you are temporarily absent through illness or injury, within limits.

What happens after I respond?

Your employer decides: no further action, a warning, or dismissal. If you are dismissed, you have 21 days to bring an unfair dismissal or general protections claim, and you generally have to choose one.

The letter came straight after I complained. Does that matter?

It may. Your employer must not take adverse action against you because you made a complaint or exercised another workplace right. A show cause letter or a suspension can sometimes be adverse action, though not always. See general protections.

What a show cause letter is for

An employer who wants to dismiss someone safely has to be able to show it told that person the reason and gave a genuine chance to answer it before deciding. The letter in front of you exists largely to create that record.

That cuts both ways. It is a step towards a possible dismissal, but it is also your one guaranteed opportunity to put your version on the file while the decision is still open. A clear, specific response written at the time is one of the most valuable documents an employee can have.

How a workplace investigation leads to the letter

Many show cause letters come at the end of a workplace investigation. The usual order is:

  1. A complaint is made, or a manager raises a concern.
  2. You may be stood down or directed to stay away from certain people while it is looked into.
  3. An investigator, inside or outside the business, interviews you and the witnesses and collects documents.
  4. The investigator reports findings to the employer.
  5. The employer writes to you with the allegations it thinks are made out, and asks you to show cause.

If you are interviewed during the investigation, the same rules apply as for the letter: answer what you know, do not guess, ask for the allegation in writing if it is vague, and keep your own note of what was asked and said.

What a fair process gives you

If you are dismissed and bring an unfair dismissal claim, the Fair Work Commission must consider the matters in s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Four of them are about the process that comes before a decision:

  • whether you were told the reason (s 387(b));
  • whether you were given an opportunity to respond to any reason about your capacity or conduct (s 387(c));
  • any unreasonable refusal to let you have a support person present at discussions about dismissal (s 387(d)); and
  • if the reason is unsatisfactory performance, whether you were warned about it before the dismissal (s 387(e)).

The Commission has held that:

Unfair dismissal protection generally needs at least 6 months' service (12 months with a small business employer), and either cover by an award or enterprise agreement or income under the high income threshold (ss 382, 383). General protections has no such requirement.

In practice a fair process gives you:

  • Know the allegations, specifically. "Concerns about your conduct" is not an allegation. You should be told what you are said to have done, when and to whom, in enough detail to answer it.
  • A real opportunity to respond before the decision is made. A meeting where the outcome is already decided is not an opportunity to respond.
  • A support person, if you ask. The law does not require your employer to offer one; what counts is an unreasonable refusal of your request. They can attend the meeting with you. They are not there to argue your case, but their presence and their notes matter.
  • Reasonable time to prepare.

If you have been stood down while the investigation runs, check your contract, award or enterprise agreement and the letter itself. Suspension pending an investigation is usually on full pay. At common law, an employer has no right to suspend an employee without pay for misconduct (Avenia v Railway & Transport Health Fund Ltd [2017] FCA 859). A contract, award, enterprise agreement or statute may give one, so check those. If your pay has stopped, ask in writing on what basis.

How long you have to respond

The letter will usually give a date, and in practice the time given is often short, a few days and rarely more than a week. The Fair Work Act sets no fixed period, though your award, enterprise agreement, contract or the employer's own policy may set a disciplinary procedure, so check those.

If you are later dismissed, a Full Bench majority has held that:

  • s 387(c) asks only whether you were given an opportunity to respond;
  • an unreasonably short deadline can still count against the employer as another relevant matter (s 387(h)); and
  • it mattered that the employee had not asked for more time (Lion Dairy and Drinks Milk Ltd v Norman [2016] FWCFB 4218).
  • If the time is too short to answer properly, ask for more in writing. Say how much and why. A refusal of a reasonable request is worth having on the record.
  • If you are unwell, on leave or waiting for documents you have asked for, say so in the same request.
  • Do not let the date pass in silence. If you cannot respond in full in time, send what you can and say what is still to come.

How to respond, step by step

  1. Read the letter twice and list each allegation in the employer's own numbering. Do not blend them into one story.
  2. Collect your documents: emails, rosters, messages, your contract and position description. Note the people who saw what happened.
  3. Answer each allegation directly: accept it, accept part of it, or deny it, then explain what actually happened.
  4. Give the context that matters, briefly. If there is an explanation, it belongs here, not in a hearing a year later.
  5. Name your evidence: documents, dates, times, and people who were there.
  6. Correct the factual errors, even small ones. An inaccuracy you let through may be treated as accepted.
  7. Raise any problem with the process: allegations too vague to answer, documents you asked for and did not get, or not enough time.
  8. Say what you want to happen next, if anything.
  9. Keep it calm and send it in writing, before the deadline. Keep a copy somewhere other than your work email.

A structure you can use

  1. A heading with your name, the date, and the date and reference of the employer's letter.
  2. One sentence saying this is your response to the allegations in that letter.
  3. Then each allegation, in the employer's numbering, with:
    1. whether you accept it, accept part of it, or deny it;
    2. what actually happened, in date order; and
    3. the documents and the people who can confirm it.
  4. Anything about the process that was unfair.
  5. Anything the employer should take into account: your length of service, your record, and any personal circumstances that bear on what happened.
  6. What you want to happen next, if anything.
  7. Your signature, and the date you sent it.

What to avoid

  • Guessing. If you do not remember, say so rather than inventing a version you may have to correct later.
  • Attacking the person who complained. Address the allegation, not the complainant.
  • Signing anything on the spot, including a deed of release or a settlement, without reading it properly.
  • Responding only out loud. Put it in writing.

Should you admit the allegations?

Only what is true. Admitting something you do not accept, to make the process end sooner, is very hard to undo, because your own response becomes the evidence against you.

But a flat denial of something that plainly happened is often worse. Where the conduct did occur, the questions that matter become whether it was serious enough to justify dismissal and whether dismissal was harsh in your circumstances. The Commission has held that:

If you are unsure how to put it, get advice before you send the response.

If you are on sick or stress leave

Being on personal leave does not by itself stop an investigation or a show cause process. What you can do is:

  1. send a medical certificate that says, if your doctor agrees, that you are not fit to take part in the process for a stated period;
  2. ask in writing for the deadline to be extended until you are fit, or to respond in writing rather than at a meeting; and
  3. keep a copy of everything you send.

An employer must not dismiss you because you are temporarily absent from work because of illness or injury (s 352). The protection has limits set by the regulations:

  • you need to give a medical certificate or statutory declaration within 24 hours after the absence starts (or a longer time that is reasonable), or give the evidence your award, agreement or the personal leave rules require; and
  • it can fall away if the absence runs past three months, or your absences total more than three months in 12 months, unless you are on paid personal leave for the whole absence.

It protects you from being dismissed for being away. It does not stop a dismissal for conduct once you have had a fair chance to answer. If your illness means you cannot respond, say so clearly and back it with medical evidence: the Commission has said that would be a material consideration (O'Connell v Wesfarmers Kleenheat Gas Pty Ltd [2015] FWCFB 8205).

If the letter came after a complaint

An employer must not take adverse action against you because you have a workplace right, or because you exercised one (s 340). A workplace right includes being able to make a complaint or inquiry about your employment (s 341(1)(c)(ii)). Adverse action includes dismissing you, injuring you in your employment, altering your position to your prejudice, and threatening to do any of those things (s 342).

Whether a show cause step is itself adverse action depends on the facts, and the courts have differed.

Either way, what usually decides the case is why the employer acted. A prohibited reason only has to be one of the reasons (s 360), and once you allege it, the employer has to prove the action was not taken for that reason (s 361). In Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [2012] HCA 32, a union officer was suspended on full pay and asked to show cause why he should not be disciplined over an email he sent to members. The High Court held that the question is the decision-maker's actual reasons at the time, and the employer won because her evidence of those reasons was accepted.

It can go the other way. In Fox v NQM Gold 2 Pty Ltd [2025] FedCFamC2G 2034, an employee on probation was stood down and given a show cause letter with two days to respond, after telling colleagues they did not have to sign new contracts that lowered their pay and complaining about being kept from training. No performance issues had been raised with him before the letter. The court found that the dismissal that followed was because of those protected actions, in breach of s 340(1). See the case study.

So if the letter arrived soon after you complained, asked about your pay, raised a safety issue or took leave, write down the dates now. Read general protections claims and Sacked for speaking up before you respond.

Performance management is different

A performance improvement plan is not an allegation of misconduct. It is an employer building a record that you were told, given a chance to improve, and did not. Where performance is the reason for a dismissal, whether you were warned is one of the things the Fair Work Commission must consider (s 387(e)).

So engage with it in writing. If the targets are unrealistic, if you have not been given the training or tools, if the workload changed, or if the plan started shortly after you did something protected, say so at the time, not afterwards. An objection made at the time is worth a great deal; the same point made a year later looks reconstructed.

Being performance managed is not, by itself, a legal claim, and reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner is not workplace bullying (s 789FD(2)). What can make it a claim is the reason behind it, or a process that is not genuine. If the plan appeared shortly after you made a complaint, asked about your pay, returned from sick leave or raised a safety issue, see general protections.

What happens after you respond

Your employer should consider your response before deciding. The usual outcomes are:

  1. no further action, or a finding that the allegations are not made out;
  2. a warning, a final warning, or other action short of dismissal, such as training or a change of duties; or
  3. dismissal, with notice or pay in lieu of notice or, for serious misconduct, without notice (s 123(1)(b)). Serious misconduct has its ordinary meaning, and the regulations give examples such as theft, fraud, assault, sexual harassment and refusing a lawful and reasonable instruction (Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) reg 1.07).

If you are dismissed, the time limits are short:

  • an unfair dismissal application must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days after the dismissal took effect (s 394(2));
  • a general protections dismissal application must be made within 21 days after the alleged dismissal took effect (s 366). Since 7 July 2026 it needs only an allegation that you were dismissed, and the Commission can start dealing with it without first deciding whether you were (ss 365, 368(1A)); and
  • you generally have to choose one claim, not both (s 725).

See the 21-day time limit.

If they offer you an exit

Many of these processes end with an offer: resign quietly, sign a deed, take a payment. Sometimes that is a good outcome. But understand what you are being asked to give up.

  • A deed of release usually ends every claim you have, including ones you have not thought of yet.
  • Your accrued annual leave is owed anyway. Untaken annual leave must be paid out when employment ends (s 90(2)). It is not something the employer is offering you.
  • Deadlines keep running while you negotiate. If you are dismissed, the 21 days runs from the dismissal, not from the end of the discussions.
  • Take the time you need. Pressure to sign today is itself worth noting.

In the WA state system

Most employees in Western Australia are in the national system and everything above applies. If you work for a sole trader, a partnership or another unincorporated employer, or for most of the WA public sector or local government, you are in the WA state system. There:

  • an unfair dismissal claim goes to the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission no later than 28 days after the day your employment ended, and the question is whether you were harshly, oppressively or unfairly dismissed (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 29); and
  • there is a narrower protection against damaging action taken because you are able to make, or made, an employment-related inquiry or complaint (Part 6B of that Act, s 97A).

See unfair dismissal in WA, WA public sector and damaging action in WA.

The short version

  • A show cause letter is your chance to put your side on the record before a decision. Use it.
  • Respond in writing, allegation by allegation, calmly and specifically.
  • Ask for particulars if they are vague, and for more time if it is too short.
  • Bring a support person to any meeting.
  • Get copies of your documents now, not later.
  • Do not resign, and do not sign anything you have not read properly.
  • If it followed a complaint, read about general protections.
  • If you are dismissed, the clock is 21 days.

Still have questions?

Three ways to talk to us. Free discussion, no obligation.

Start AI chat1300 967 552