Can you claim? Four questions before fairness
Before the Commission looks at whether your dismissal was fair, you have to clear four threshold questions. The time limit is a fifth, covered below. Fail one and the merits are never examined, however badly you were treated.
Read moreShow less
1. Were you dismissed?
Dismissal means your employment ended at the employer's initiative. It also includes being forced to resign because of the employer's conduct, or a course of conduct, which is often called constructive dismissal (s 386(1)). A genuine resignation is not a dismissal, and neither is the end of a genuine fixed-term contract, a training arrangement, or a demotion that does not significantly cut your pay or duties (s 386(2)).
2. Have you worked there long enough?
| Your employer | Minimum employment period |
|---|---|
| Small business: fewer than 15 employees | 12 months |
| Everyone else | 6 months |
- The minimum employment period is counted to the earlier of when you were given notice and the dismissal itself (s 383). Two rules catch people out:
- the small business headcount includes the dismissed employee, regular casuals and employees of associated entities, so a business that feels small may not be one in law (s 23); and
- time as a casual counts only if you were a regular casual and had a reasonable expectation of continuing work on a regular and systematic basis (s 384(2)(a)).
3. Are you covered by an award, an agreement, or under the threshold?
You need one of these: a modern award covers your job, an enterprise agreement applies to you, or you earn less than the high income threshold, which is $190,100 from 1 July 2026, superannuation excluded (s 382). The threshold is indexed every 1 July, and the figure that counts is the one in force on the day you were dismissed. Check it on the Fair Work Commission's website. If an award or agreement covers you, your income does not matter.
4. Was it a genuine redundancy, or did the small business code apply?
- A genuine redundancy is not unfair dismissal (s 389). It is genuine only if:
- the employer no longer needed anyone to do your job, because of changes in its operational requirements;
- the employer consulted you as any modern award or enterprise agreement required; and
- it would not have been reasonable to redeploy you within the business or an associated entity.
- A small business employer that followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code is treated as having dismissed you fairly (s 388). Under the Code:
- dismissal without notice or warning is fair if the employer believed on reasonable grounds that your conduct was serious enough to justify it, such as theft, fraud or violence; and
- in any other case the employer must give you a valid reason based on your conduct or capacity, warn you that you risk dismissal if there is no improvement, give you a chance to respond and a reasonable chance to fix the problem.

Keystroke data from her laptop ended a career of almost 18 years
Read the full storyShow less
Suzie Cheikho joined Insurance Australia Group in May 2005. Her work included lodging documents with the financial regulator, ASIC, and it all had to be done on her company laptop. Her managers had raised concerns during that year: a letter setting out their expectations in June, a missed lodgement that, her manager said, led to a fine from ASIC, a formal written warning in November and, in December, a performance improvement plan.
As part of that plan, the insurer reviewed her laptop activity from 1 October to 16 December 2022. It reported that she had not worked her rostered hours on 44 of 49 working days and had done no work at all on four of them. In October alone there were 117 working hours with no keystrokes. Her monthly average ranged from about 35 to 80 keystrokes an hour. She was dismissed on 20 February 2023.
Ms Cheikho said she doubted the data, and that she had sometimes used other devices. In her written response to the insurer she also said she had been going through personal issues that had affected her mental health and, she believed, her work.
Deputy President Roberts found that there were 'extended periods' when she was not working as required. Her job could only be done on the laptop and the company network, and although she had access to the insurer's systems after the allegations were put to her, she did not show what work she had actually done. That was misconduct, and a valid reason for dismissal. She had been told of the concerns, met the insurer with a union support person, and given two chances to respond in writing.
Her long and satisfactory service counted in her favour, and the Deputy President accepted that the problems behind her disconnection from work were 'serious and real'. It was not enough. The dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and her application was dismissed.
Activity data from a work laptop can be enough to prove you were not working, even after many years of good service. If your health is affecting your work, it is worth raising it early rather than waiting until an investigation has started.
The 21-day time limit
You must lodge within 21 days after the dismissal took effect (s 394(2)). These are calendar days, and the day of the dismissal is not counted. The full detail, including when the clock starts, is in the 21-day deadline.
Read moreShow less
- The Commission can allow more time only if there are exceptional circumstances (s 394(3)). It takes into account:
- the reason for the delay;
- whether you first became aware of the dismissal after it took effect;
- anything you did to dispute the dismissal;
- prejudice to the employer, including prejudice caused by the delay;
- the merits of the application; and
- fairness between you and others in a similar position.
Exceptional means out of the ordinary course, unusual or special, and not knowing about the time limit is not enough on its own (Nulty v Blue Star Group Pty Ltd [2011] FWAFB 975).
What makes a dismissal unfair
The Commission must consider each of the matters in s 387 of the Fair Work Act. In practice they fall into two questions. A dismissal can be unjust because you did not do what you were accused of, unreasonable because it was based on conclusions the evidence did not support, or harsh because of its consequences for you, or because it was out of proportion to the conduct (Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd [1995] HCA 24).
Read moreShow less
Was there a valid reason?
A valid reason is one that is sound, defensible or well founded, not capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced (Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd [1995] IRCA 333). It must relate to your capacity or your conduct, including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees. The Commission decides for itself whether the conduct happened. It does not simply accept what the employer believed.
Was the process fair?
- Were you told the reason before the decision was made?
- Did you get a real opportunity to respond?
- Did the employer unreasonably refuse to let you bring a support person to discussions about dismissal?
- If it was about performance, were you warned first?
- Does the size of the business, and whether it has HR staff, explain any shortcomings in the process?
Then anything else relevant: your length of service, your record, how others were treated for the same conduct, and the effect of the dismissal on you. A valid reason can still be outweighed by a process that was badly unfair, and a flawed process does not always make a dismissal for serious misconduct unfair.

Fooled by an email scammer, the bank manager got her job back
Read the full storyShow less
Kylie Smith had been promoted from customer service officer to branch manager at the Bank of Queensland in Nambour. In the first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic the branch was busy and short of staff, it had no lender, and she was about to go on leave. She was asked to finish a kind of loan she had never handled: a builder's final $37,500 construction payment.
On 1 April 2020, emails in the customer's email chain asked her to hold the payment because he was 'missing on some payments', and then to pay it into a Commonwealth Bank account instead. They came from a fraudster. She wrote the new account details onto a form the customer had signed in 2018, had a colleague who had not prepared the form sign as its 'preparer', authorised the payment herself, and did not phone the customer. The bank lost about $30,000. It dismissed her on 8 May 2020.
Deputy President Asbury found that she had missed red flags and come 'close to crossing the line between carelessness and negligence', but had not crossed it. Her failure to follow procedure was not wilful. She had not been trained for this kind of fraud, the fake emails were not strikingly odd and their hidden technical tells were apparent only in hindsight, the branch was under real pressure, and the bank had contributed: the pre-signed form should never have existed. Her remorse was genuine. Dismissal was not a sound response, so there was no valid reason for it.
Nor was she told the real reason, her manager's loss of trust in her, so she could not answer it. In a separate decision on 19 April 2021, the Deputy President ordered the bank to reinstate her as Nambour branch manager and to pay her lost wages of $48,282.83 plus $6,200.36 in superannuation. Meanwhile she had retrained, and was working in aged care on $23.09 an hour.
An honest mistake, even a costly one, is not automatically a valid reason for dismissal. The Commission looks at your training, the pressure you were under, what the employer itself contributed, and your record.
The remedy was decided separately: Smith v Bank of Queensland Ltd [2021] FWC 2060 (19 April 2021).
Unfair dismissal payouts: what you can get
Reinstatement, meaning your job back, is the primary remedy in the Act. The Commission can order compensation only if it is satisfied that reinstatement is inappropriate and that compensation is appropriate (s 390(3)). The Commission itself says reinstatement is rare: in 2024–25 it ordered it in 9 of 263 decided cases, and most successful decided claims ended in compensation (Fair Work Commission outcomes).
Read moreShow less
How the amount is worked out
The Commission follows a set method, which in outline runs as below (Bowden v Ottrey Homes Cobram and District Retirement Villages Inc T/A Ottrey Lodge [2013] FWCFB 431 at [24], applying the steps in Sprigg v Paul's Licensed Festival Supermarket [1998] AIRC 989). It weighs every factor in s 392(2), including the employer's viability, your length of service and your efforts to find other work.
- What you would have earned if you had not been dismissed, including how long the job was likely to have lasted.
- Less what you have earned since, and what you are likely to earn, from other work.
- Less a discount for contingencies, such as the chance the job would have ended anyway.
- Less a reduction if your own misconduct contributed to the dismissal (s 392(3)).
- Then the cap: the lesser of your pay for the 26 weeks before the dismissal (what you received or were entitled to, whichever is higher) and half the high income threshold, which is $95,050 for a dismissal from 1 July 2026 (s 392(5)–(6)).
| How it works | |
|---|---|
| Hurt and distress | Not compensable. Unfair dismissal compensation is for lost earnings only (s 392(4)). |
| Your own conduct | Compensation must be reduced where your misconduct contributed to the dismissal. |
| Looking for work | You are expected to look for other work. Failing to do so can reduce the award (s 392(2)(d)). |
| The cap | 26 weeks' pay or $95,050, whichever is less. It is a ceiling, not a target. |
Most people receive far less than the cap. The Fair Work Commission says the median compensation is between 5 and 7 weeks' pay, and fewer than 0.4% of applicants receive the maximum (Fair Work Commission, compensation).
Most claims never reach a hearing. The Commission lists a conciliation first, and says about three in four cases are resolved there. A settlement can include a sum of money, an agreed reference or a changed reason for leaving, in exchange for a release of your claims.
What happens after you lodge
- Lodge Form F2 with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days. There is a filing fee, which can be waived if paying it would cause you serious hardship.
- The employer responds on Form F3, within 7 days after it is served with your application, and may raise an objection, for example that you were not dismissed or that it was a genuine redundancy.
- Conciliation: a confidential online meeting of about 90 minutes with a Commission conciliator, usually 2 to 5 weeks after you lodge. Many matters settle here.
- If it does not settle, the matter goes to a Commission member for a conference or a hearing, and a decision. For applications made from 7 July 2026, the Commission can also decide it on the papers if both sides agree and it thinks the matter can be decided that way (s 397(2)).
Read moreShow less
The Commission sets out the steps on its process page.






