No web page can tell you for certain that you have a case. This one gives you the questions, and what usually decides each of them. For the full guide to claims, the process and payouts, see unfair dismissal. If you worked in Western Australia for a sole trader, a partnership of individuals, another unincorporated employer, most of the State public sector or a council, different rules and a 28-day limit apply: see unfair dismissal in WA.
First: the deadline
The Commission can extend the deadline, but only in exceptional circumstances, and that bar is high. Not knowing about the time limit is not, on its own, an exceptional circumstance (Nulty v Blue Star Group Pty Ltd [2011] FWAFB 975).
Questions 1 to 4: can you claim at all?
This is the part that surprises people. Before the Commission considers whether your dismissal was unfair, it must decide some threshold questions. If you fail any one of them, the merits of your case are never examined, however badly you were treated.
1. Were you dismissed?
Dismissal means the employment ended at the employer's initiative. That includes being sacked outright. It also includes being forced to resign, where the employer's conduct left you no real choice. A genuine resignation is not a dismissal, and neither is the ordinary end of a fixed-term contract.
2. Have you been there long enough?
| Your employer | Minimum time you must have worked |
|---|---|
| Small business (fewer than 15 employees) | 12 months |
| Everyone else (15 or more employees) | 6 months |
The headcount includes regular casuals, and associated entities are counted as one employer, so a business that feels small may not be. Getting this wrong in either direction is common, and it doubles or halves the period you need.
3. Are you covered by an award, an agreement, or under the threshold?
You need one of the following: a modern award covers your job, an enterprise agreement applies to you, or you earn less than the high income threshold. The threshold is $190,100 a year from 1 July 2026. It is indexed on 1 July each year, so confirm the current figure on the Fair Work Commission website before you rely on it.
4. Was it a genuine redundancy, or did the small business code apply?
- If it was a genuine redundancy, you cannot bring an unfair dismissal claim. But "genuine" has a specific meaning, and three things must all be true:
- the job (not the person) is no longer required;
- the employer consulted as any applicable award or agreement required; and
- there was no reasonable redeployment available in the business or an associated entity.
Failing the consultation step alone is enough for the employer to lose the redundancy exclusion.
If your employer is a small business and followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, for example by warning you and giving you a chance to improve, the dismissal is treated as fair. The unfair dismissal guide sets out what the Code requires.
Questions 5 and 6: was it unfair?
If you clear the threshold questions, the Commission asks whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. It works through a list of criteria in s 387 of the Fair Work Act, and it weighs them together. There is no single knockout factor.
5. Was there a valid reason?
A valid reason must be sound, defensible or well founded, not capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced (Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd [1995] IRCA 333). Two things follow from that, and they cut in both directions:
- The employer cannot just rely on believing you did it. The Commission makes its own finding, on the evidence, about whether the conduct happened.
- The Commission will not substitute its own judgement either. It is not asking what it would have done in the employer's chair. A reason can be valid even if another employer would have been more lenient.
Proven serious misconduct will be a valid reason. Misconduct is not necessary, though: plenty of valid reasons fall well short of it, including genuine performance problems.
6. Was the process fair?
A fair process matters as much as the reason. The Commission considers whether you were:
- told the reason for the dismissal, in terms you could understand;
- given a real opportunity to respond to it, before the decision was made, not after;
- allowed a support person, if you asked for one;
- warned about poor performance, where performance was the reason; and
- affected by the employer's size or lack of dedicated HR expertise. A small business is held to a more practical standard, but not to no standard at all.
If the answers point to unfair: what you could get
Reinstatement is the primary remedy, but the Fair Work Commission's figures show that in decided cases most successful claims end in compensation for lost earnings. Compensation is capped at 26 weeks' pay or half the high income threshold, whichever is less, and hurt and distress are not compensated. How the amount is worked out, and what happens after you lodge, are in unfair dismissal payouts.
The most common mistakes
- Missing the 21 days. By far the most frequent way a good case dies.
- Choosing the wrong claim. Unfair dismissal is not the only option, and it is sometimes the wrong one — being sacked for a prohibited reason is a general protections claim, with different rules but the same 21-day deadline.
- Expecting damages for distress. Compensation covers lost earnings only.
- Resigning first. A resignation can end your ability to claim unless you can show you were forced into it, which is a harder case to run.
- Going quiet at conciliation. Turning up unprepared to the one step where most matters resolve is the cheapest mistake to avoid.
Still have questions?
Three ways to talk to us. Free discussion, no obligation.