HomeIndustrial hubUnions in the NSW state systemBargaining, disputes and industrial action
Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW) Ch 2A and Ch 3

Bargaining, disputes and industrial action. Conciliation, then arbitration.

The NSW state system has no protected industrial action. Bargaining that stalls goes to the Industrial Relations Commission for conciliation and, if needed, arbitration, and a dispute order can make continued action a contravention. This is a short guide; a fuller one is coming.

$10,000maximum penalty for the first day of a first contravention of a dispute order (IR Act s 139(4))
$25,000maximum civil penalty for breaching a final order or determination made in arbitration under s 136(1)(d) (IR Act s 136A)
100 penalty unitsmaximum for an employer paying strike pay (IR Act s 143)
A line drawing of two groups of people seated on either side of a long table in a hearing room, with a commission member at a raised bench at the end and water jugs on the table

Key figures

WhatFigureSource
Contravening a dispute order, first timeUp to $10,000 for the first day and $5,000 for each later dayIR Act s 139(4)(a)
Contravening a dispute order, after an earlier penaltyUp to $20,000 for the first day and $10,000 for each later dayIR Act s 139(4)(b)
Breaching a final order or determination under s 136(1)(d)Civil penalty up to $25,000IR Act s 136A
Employer paying for time on strikeOffence, up to 100 penalty unitsIR Act s 143(1)
Members who can ask the IRC for a secret ballot5 per cent of the union's members or 250 members, whichever is fewerIR Act s 172(5)(b)
Contravening a dispute order, first timeFigure: Up to $10,000 for the first day and $5,000 for each later day
Source
IR Act s 139(4)(a)
Contravening a dispute order, after an earlier penaltyFigure: Up to $20,000 for the first day and $10,000 for each later day
Source
IR Act s 139(4)(b)
Breaching a final order or determination under s 136(1)(d)Figure: Civil penalty up to $25,000
Source
IR Act s 136A
Employer paying for time on strikeFigure: Offence, up to 100 penalty units
Source
IR Act s 143(1)
Members who can ask the IRC for a secret ballotFigure: 5 per cent of the union's members or 250 members, whichever is fewer
Source
IR Act s 172(5)(b)

The short version

  1. The Act's object is to resolve industrial disputes by conciliation and, if necessary, arbitration (s 3(g)). It has no protected industrial action and no protected action ballots.
  2. Mutual gains bargaining under Chapter 2A is voluntary. If it fails, it can be declared unresolved and goes to the IRC as an industrial dispute (ss 129K, 129P, 129Q).
  3. A union, an employer or the State peak council may notify the IRC of a dispute. An individual employee cannot (s 130).
  4. The IRC conciliates first, and arbitrates only after it certifies that reasonable attempts at conciliation were made (ss 133-136).
  5. In arbitration the IRC may make dispute orders, including an order to stop industrial action. Contravening one can lead the Industrial Court to impose penalties, suspend award entitlements or cancel a union's registration (ss 137-139).

Industrial action in the state system

  1. What it is. Industrial action is a strike or lock-out, including work bans, limitations and refusals to work adopted in connection with an industrial dispute, but not action taken with the other side's agreement (IR Act Dictionary).
  2. What the Act provides. There is nothing like the Fair Work Act's protected action. The IR Act provides only:
    1. dispute orders that require a person to stop industrial action (s 137);
    2. a temporary bar on suing a union in tort, and on injunctions, while the IRC is conciliating the dispute (ss 140-142);
    3. a ban on strike pay (s 143).
  3. What a dispute can be about. An industrial dispute is a dispute, question or difficulty about an industrial matter, including a threatened or likely dispute (Dictionary). Industrial matters are matters affecting or relating to work done or to be done, or the rights and duties of employers or employees in an industry (s 6). Since 3 July 2025 they include the return to work of injured employees (s 6(2)(e1)), for employees who are not national system employees (s 146E).

Mutual gains bargaining

  1. Voluntary. Chapter 2A, in force since 15 December 2023, applies if a union or employer organisation and an employer have agreed to enter mutual gains bargaining (s 129K). Any of them may give the IRC written notice of intention to start (s 129N). During conciliation the IRC may recommend it (s 134(2D)).
  2. Principles. It is collaborative and consensus-seeking: the parties identify their key needs, aim for an agreement that maximises common interests, and aim to strengthen their relationship (s 129L).
  3. Good faith. In mutual gains bargaining, good faith means (s 129M):
    1. attending and taking part in meetings requested at reasonable times;
    2. giving relevant information as soon as practicable, including information about gender equality in the workplace;
    3. considering the other side's proposals and responding with reasons;
    4. not acting capriciously or unfairly in a way that undermines the bargaining.
  4. Good faith does not require concessions or agreement (s 129M(2)). The IRC acts as facilitator unless the parties choose a third party or none (s 129O).
  5. When it fails. The facilitator, or one or both parties, may declare the bargaining unresolved, with a report on whether the parties bargained in good faith and what remains in dispute (s 129P). Before a 2025 amendment, only the facilitator could make the declaration where one had been appointed (Health Secretary v Australian Salaried Medical Officers' Federation (New South Wales) [2026] NSWIC 13 at [107]). The declaration is taken to be a dispute notification, and in arbitrating it the IRC must consider the parties' conduct and whether they bargained in good faith (s 129Q).
  6. Industrial action does not fit with it. In [2026] NSWIC 13 the Industrial Court gave no mitigating weight to strike action taken in defiance of dispute orders after the employer left mutual gains bargaining: the process is cooperative, unresolved bargaining moves into conciliation and arbitration, and the employer had stayed willing to use conciliation and arbitration (at [103]-[111]).

Notifying a dispute, conciliation and arbitration

  1. Who may notify. Any of these may notify the IRC of an industrial dispute, and the IRC may also act on its own initiative (s 130):
    1. an industrial organisation of employees or employers;
    2. an employer who is or is likely to be affected;
    3. a person who is or is likely to be the subject of a secondary boycott;
    4. a State peak council.
  2. Dispute procedures first. The IRC may refuse to deal with a dispute until any procedure in the award or agreement has been followed as far as reasonably practicable (s 131). It may call a compulsory conference (s 132).
  3. Conciliation. Conciliation comes first (s 133). The IRC may make recommendations or give directions whether or not a party consents; a failure to comply is not penalised, but it may be taken into account, and a party that does not comply must give written reasons (s 134(2)-(2C)). The IRC must consider whether the parties have bargained in good faith, including disclosure of information about gender equality, and may direct them to do so (s 134(4)).
  4. The certificate. Arbitration cannot start until the IRC certifies that reasonable attempts at conciliation have been made (s 135). It must issue the certificate without delay if:
    1. a person entitled to notify the dispute satisfies it that conciliation has no reasonable likelihood of success (s 135(6)); or
    2. it decides that industrial action or duress makes it necessary to use its arbitral powers (s 135(7)).
  5. Arbitration. The IRC may make a recommendation or direction, make or vary an award, make a dispute order, or make an interim or final order or determination, including about the interpretation or application of an industrial instrument (s 136). Contravening a final order or determination of that last kind carries a civil penalty of up to $25,000 (s 136A).
  6. A ballot of members. The IRC may order a secret ballot of employees on an industrial matter, on its own initiative or on the application of an affected union, or of 5 per cent of a union's members or 250 members, whichever is fewer. The State bears the cost (s 172).

Dispute orders and penalties

  1. The orders. In arbitration the IRC may order (s 137):
    1. that a person stop or refrain from industrial action;
    2. that an employer reinstate or re-employ employees dismissed in the course of the dispute, or whose dismissal caused it;
    3. that an employer not carry out a threat to dismiss employees in the course of the dispute;
    4. that a person stop a secondary boycott.
  2. Where employees are taking industrial action, the IRC may order them to stop before making any other dispute order against the employer, and a dispute order cannot provide for compensation or lost pay (s 137(2)-(3)). An order may bind a party, or a member, officer or employee of a union that is a party (s 138).
  3. An example. In December 2024 the IRC made dispute orders restraining a union from coordinating, organising or facilitating a mass resignation of psychiatrists ([2026] NSWIC 13 at [25]).
  4. Contravention. The Industrial Court deals with an alleged contravention, after summoning the person to show cause (ss 139, 153(1)(d)). It may (s 139(3)):
    1. dismiss the matter or take no action;
    2. cancel the approval of an enterprise agreement, or suspend or modify entitlements under an instrument;
    3. cancel a union's registration;
    4. impose a penalty on a union or an employer;
    5. make any other determination that would help resolve the dispute.
  5. How penalties are fixed. The Court adopted the High Court's approach that civil penalties are imposed primarily for deterrence, qualified for s 139 because the Court may also make a determination that helps resolve the dispute, and because it matters whether the dispute is still live (Secretary, Ministry of Health v New South Wales Nurses and Midwives' Association [2025] NSWIC 20 at [90]-[99]).
Case study
Penalties totalling $130,000Industrial Court of New South Wales · 12 November 2025

$130,000 for strikes in breach of dispute orders

During the 2024 public health nurses' pay campaign, industrial action continued on several days after the IRC ordered it to stop.

Read the full storyShow less

The IRC made dispute orders requiring the nurses' union to stop industrial action. The action continued on several days in September and November 2024.

The Health Secretary sought penalties under s 139. The Court adopted the High Court's approach in Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13: civil penalties are imposed primarily for deterrence, and proportionality to the seriousness of the conduct is not a limit (at [90]-[92]).

It qualified that approach for s 139, following two Supreme Court decisions: the Court may make any other determination that would help resolve the dispute, and whether the dispute is still live is relevant (at [97]-[99]).

Penalties of $21,000, $4,000, $49,000 and $56,000 were imposed for contraventions of dispute orders made on 9 September, 18 September and 8 November 2024 (orders (1)(a)-(d)).

What it means for you

Penalties for contravening a dispute order are set for deterrence. Under s 139 the Court can also make orders aimed at resolving the dispute.

Case study
Penalty of $30,500Industrial Court of New South Wales · 17 April 2026

Striking to restart mutual gains bargaining

NSW Health withdrew from mutual gains bargaining with the doctors' union, and the union struck in breach of dispute orders to bring it back.

Read the full storyShow less

On a Commissioner's recommendation, NSW Health and the union entered mutual gains bargaining in 2024 with an independent facilitator (at [21]-[23]). NSW Health withdrew in early 2025. The union notified a dispute, withdrew the notification, and threatened action unless bargaining resumed (at [30]-[31]).

The union took action from 2 to 10 April 2025 in breach of dispute orders made on 1 April 2025. A penalty of $30,500 was imposed (order (1)), within the range of $25,000 to $35,000 that the parties agreed (at [8]).

The union said its motive was to hold the employer to mutual gains bargaining. The Court gave that no exculpatory or mitigating weight (at [103]): coercion is the negation of cooperation (at [104]); unresolved bargaining moves into conciliation and arbitration under ss 129P and 129Q (at [105]-[106]); the union could always notify a dispute under s 130 (at [108]); and NSW Health had stayed willing to use conciliation and arbitration (at [111]).

What it means for you

The Act's route when mutual gains bargaining ends is a dispute notification and arbitration, in which bargaining conduct counts (s 129Q).

Torts, strike pay and stand-downs

  1. Torts while the IRC conciliates. No action in tort may be brought or continued against a union, or its officials or members, for acts in contemplation or furtherance of an industrial dispute while the dispute is subject to conciliation, and no court may grant an injunction to restrain such a tort while it is not actionable (ss 140-142). The period runs from notification, or the IRC's decision to act, until a certificate of attempted conciliation issues or the proceedings end (s 141(2)-(3)). It does not cover death, personal injury, property damage, defamation and some other actions (s 140(2)).
  2. Strike pay. An employer who pays for time spent in industrial action commits an offence, unless the IRC authorises the payment on a union's application because the action was based on a reasonable concern for health or safety (s 143). A refusal to work is not based on such a concern if the employees refused a direction to move to a safe place and do other suitable work (s 143(5)).
  3. Stand-downs. On an employer's application the IRC may order the stand-down of employees who have no useful work because of industrial action or another cause the employer is not responsible for. The period counts as service (s 126).

Not settled

Since 3 July 2025 taking part in industrial action the union organises is an industrial organising activity protected from victimisation (s 209(3), s 210(1)). How the IRC reconciles that protection with a dispute order that makes continued action unlawful, and whether a member disciplined for defying a dispute order can claim victimisation, has not been decided in any decision found for this guide.

For unions and industrial officers

Send us the job. Get back cited research and a first draft.

Agreement interpretation, disputes, FWC applications and show-cause replies. Built on more than 400,000 Australian decisions, with a separate checking pass on every draft.

Questions

The things people ask.

Do members need a ballot before taking industrial action?

The IR Act has no protected action ballot. It does not make industrial action lawful in the way the Fair Work Act does. The IRC can order a secret ballot of employees on an industrial matter, including on the application of 5 per cent of a union's members or 250 members, whichever is fewer (IR Act s 172).

Can a member notify a dispute personally?

No. Only a union or employer organisation, an affected employer, a person subject to a secondary boycott or the State peak council may notify a dispute, and the IRC may act on its own initiative (IR Act s 130).

What happens if action continues after a dispute order?

The Industrial Court may impose penalties of up to $10,000 for the first day and $5,000 for each later day of a first contravention, more for a repeat, and may also suspend award entitlements, cancel an agreement's approval or cancel the union's registration (IR Act s 139(3)-(4)).

Can members be paid for strike days?

No. Paying for time spent in industrial action is an offence for the employer, except a payment the IRC authorises on a union's application where the action was based on a reasonable concern for health or safety (IR Act s 143).

The employer has walked away from mutual gains bargaining. What can the union do?

Notify an industrial dispute to the IRC under s 130. A party may also declare the bargaining unresolved, which is taken to be a dispute notification (ss 129P, 129Q). The Industrial Court has said that industrial action taken to force the employer back carries no mitigating weight ([2026] NSWIC 13 at [103]-[111]).