HomeIndustrial hubUnions in the WA state systemIndustrial agreements and bargaining
Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) Part II Division 2B

Industrial agreements and bargaining. A notice, a duty and a register.

In the WA state system a collective agreement is made between a registered union and an employer, and becomes an industrial agreement only when the WAIRC registers it. The statutory bargaining rights start with a written notice that has to be exactly right.

90 daysbefore the old agreement's nominal expiry date, the earliest a s 42 notice can be given (s 42(5))
21 daysfor the other side to say whether it will bargain, extendable by up to 7 days (s 42A(1)-(2))
3 yearsthe longest nominal term a registered agreement can have (s 41A(1)(a))
A line drawing of union officials and managers seated on either side of a long meeting table, with a thick draft agreement, coffee cups and notepads between them

Words used on this page:

  1. an organisation is a union registered under the IR Act (s 7). Only an organisation or association of employees, an employer or an employers' body can be a party to an industrial agreement (s 41(1));
  2. an industrial agreement is an agreement registered by the Commission under s 41 (s 7). Until it is registered it is not an industrial instrument;
  3. a negotiating party is the party that started bargaining with a s 42 notice, or a party that agreed to bargain in response (s 40C);
  4. an enterprise order is an instrument the Commission makes in place of an agreement when bargaining has failed or the other side refused to bargain (ss 42I to 42K).

Section numbers on this page are of the IR Act unless another Act is named. A federal enterprise agreement under the Fair Work Act is a different instrument with different rules.

Key time limits

StepTimeSource
Earliest s 42 notice when an agreement or enterprise order is in forceNot earlier than 90 days before its nominal expiry date. If none is in force, at any timeIR Act s 42(4), (5)
Response to a s 42 noticeWithin 21 days of receiving it; the Commission may extend by no more than 7 days, even on a late applications 42A(1)-(3)
Filing the notice or response with the RegistrarAt least 7 days before it is relied on in any proceeding or conferenceGeneral Regulations reg 14(1)
Enterprise order after a s 42H declarationWithin 21 days after the declarations 42I(3)(a)
Enterprise order after no response or a refusalWithin 21 days after the end of the response periods 42I(3)(b)
Nominal term of an industrial agreementNo later than 3 years after it comes into operations 41A(1)(a)
Term of an enterprise orderAn expiry day no more than 2 years after it comes into operations 42K(2)
Hearing an application to register an agreementNot listed until 14 days after publication, unless the Commission directs otherwiseCommission Regulations reg 55(3)
Notice of retirement from an expired agreementFiled at any time after expiry, or not more than 30 days before it; takes effect 30 days after filings 41(7)
Appeal to the Full BenchWithin 21 days of the decision. No appeal from a s 42G order or a s 42H declarationss 49(3), 42G(6), 42H(2)
Earliest s 42 notice when an agreement or enterprise order is in forceTime: Not earlier than 90 days before its nominal expiry date. If none is in force, at any time
Source
IR Act s 42(4), (5)
Response to a s 42 noticeTime: Within 21 days of receiving it; the Commission may extend by no more than 7 days, even on a late application
Source
s 42A(1)-(3)
Filing the notice or response with the RegistrarTime: At least 7 days before it is relied on in any proceeding or conference
Source
General Regulations reg 14(1)
Enterprise order after a s 42H declarationTime: Within 21 days after the declaration
Source
s 42I(3)(a)
Show all 10 rowsShow fewer
Enterprise order after no response or a refusalTime: Within 21 days after the end of the response period
Source
s 42I(3)(b)
Nominal term of an industrial agreementTime: No later than 3 years after it comes into operation
Source
s 41A(1)(a)
Term of an enterprise orderTime: An expiry day no more than 2 years after it comes into operation
Source
s 42K(2)
Hearing an application to register an agreementTime: Not listed until 14 days after publication, unless the Commission directs otherwise
Source
Commission Regulations reg 55(3)
Notice of retirement from an expired agreementTime: Filed at any time after expiry, or not more than 30 days before it; takes effect 30 days after filing
Source
s 41(7)
Appeal to the Full BenchTime: Within 21 days of the decision. No appeal from a s 42G order or a s 42H declaration
Source
ss 49(3), 42G(6), 42H(2)

The short version

  1. Every WA collective agreement has a registered union as a party. Individual employees cannot make one, and the only individual agreements the IR Act allows cannot be made while an industrial agreement is in force (City of Cockburn v WASU [2023] WAIRC 00787 at [130]-[133]).
  2. Bargaining can happen informally (s 42(7)), but the statutory rights (the good faith duty, s 42E orders, s 42H declarations and enterprise orders) attach only to bargaining started with a s 42 notice that gives every required particular.
  3. The other side has 21 days to say whether it will bargain (s 42A). Silence or a refusal opens the way to an enterprise order (s 42I(1)(b)).
  4. While bargaining, each negotiating party must bargain in good faith (s 42B), but no one has to agree to anything (s 42D). The Commission can make orders to help bargaining (s 42E), and can decide outstanding terms only if all the negotiating parties ask (s 42G).
  5. Once the parties agree, the Commission must register the agreement if it meets s 41 and s 41A. Its power to require changes is narrow (s 41(3)).
  6. After the nominal expiry date the agreement keeps running until it is replaced, but any party can retire from it on 30 days' notice (s 41(6)-(7)).

General information, not legal advice. Several steps on this page are counted from a date the other side controls; diarise them when the notice is served.

How Division 2B is built

Part II Division 2B of the IR Act separates three things (City of Canning v WASU [2026] WAIRC 00005 at [224]):

Read moreShow less
  1. bargaining: starting it (s 42), responding (s 42A) and the duty of good faith (ss 42B to 42F);
  2. making and registering the agreement (ss 41, 41A); and
  3. what happens when bargaining fails or a party will not bargain: terms set by the Commission at the parties' joint request (s 42G), a declaration that bargaining has ended (s 42H), and an enterprise order (ss 42I to 42K).

Being a negotiating party is not the same as being a party to the agreement. A union that bargained has no right to be named as a party to the agreement the others make ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [224]-[229]).

Starting bargaining: the s 42 notice

Who may give it, and to whom

A union, an employer or an employers' organisation may start bargaining by giving an intended party a written notice that complies with s 42(3) (IR Act s 42(1)). A notice may be given to an employers' organisation only if it has agreed in writing (s 42(2)).

What it must contain

The notice must be accompanied by particulars of (s 42(3)):

  1. the types of employment the agreement is to cover;
  2. the area in which it is to operate;
  3. the intended parties; and
  4. anything else the regulations prescribe.

The notice may be given in the form GFB 1, and must be accompanied by all the particulars that form sets out (General Regulations reg 12). GFB 1 is a public form in Schedule 3 to the General Regulations.

Strict compliance

The particulars must actually be given. "It is not enough for the particulars to be easy or reasonably easy to work out from all of the surrounding circumstances"; s 42(3) "must be actually, and not substantially, complied with" (Western Australian Police Union of Workers v Commissioner of Police [2016] WAIRC 00685 at [10]). The Commission gave two reasons: compliance is easy because form GFB 1 exists, and the notice triggers a statutory regime that can end in arbitration, so the parties must know exactly where they stand (at [11]).

A later decision held that a GFB 1 giving all three particulars complied, and that there is "no warrant to read the requirements of the IR Act narrowly or by incorporating legal principles mined from the cases" (CFMEUW v City of Canning [2026] WAIRC 00523, Schedule 1 at [13]-[14]). Other unions named as intended parties need not consent before they are named (Schedule 1 at [15]).

Several unions

A notice may seek an agreement wider than one union's coverage if the intended agreement is a multi-union agreement within the unions' combined eligibility, by naming the other unions as intended parties ([2026] WAIRC 00523, Schedule 1 at [10]-[11]). All negotiating parties bargain together unless the Commission, on a negotiating party's application, lets it negotiate separately with the initiating party (s 42(6)). Section 42(6) is about bargaining, not about who must be a party to the registered agreement ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [207]-[208]).

When it may be given, and filing it
  1. If no industrial agreement or enterprise order applies, at any time (s 42(4)).
  2. If one is in force, not earlier than 90 days before its nominal expiry date (s 42(5), (8)).
  3. A copy of the notice, and of any response, must be filed with the Registrar at least 7 days before it is relied on in a proceeding or conference before the Commission (General Regulations reg 14(1)).

The response, and the duty of good faith

The 21-day response
  1. The person given the notice may tell the initiating party within 21 days of receiving it whether it will bargain (s 42A(1)). Form GFB 2 may be used (General Regulations reg 13).
  2. The Commission may extend that time by no more than 7 days, even if the application is made after the 21 days have run (s 42A(2)-(3)). An extension application bars and stays any enterprise order application until it is decided or withdrawn (s 42A(5)).
  3. Bargaining is initiated when the recipient says it will bargain (s 42A(6)).
  4. No response within the time, or a refusal, is itself a gateway to an enterprise order (s 42I(1)(b)).
What good faith requires

"When bargaining for an industrial agreement, a negotiating party must bargain in good faith" (s 42B(1)). Without limiting the expression, it includes (s 42B(2)):

  1. stating a position on the matters at issue, and explaining it;
  2. meeting at reasonable times, intervals and places for face-to-face bargaining;
  3. disclosing relevant and necessary information for bargaining;
  4. acting honestly and openly, including not capriciously adding or withdrawing items;
  5. recognising bargaining agents;
  6. providing reasonable facilities to union representatives that they need to carry out their functions;
  7. bargaining genuinely and putting enough resources into it; and
  8. sticking to agreed outcomes and commitments.
What it does not require

No negotiating party has to agree to include or leave out any matter, or to make an agreement at all (s 42D). The Commission cannot order a party to make an agreement or to include or leave out a matter, except by a s 42G order the parties ask for (s 42F; [2026] WAIRC 00005 at [241]-[243]).

Industrial action during bargaining

"The Commission may, having regard to the circumstances in which the industrial action occurs, determine that engaging in industrial action is a breach of the duty to bargain in good faith" (s 42B(3)). So industrial action is not necessarily a breach (SSTU v Director-General, Department of Education and Training [2008] WAIRC 00364 at [75]). In that case the Acting President counted it as relevant that the stoppage was set for the middle of a short period in which the employer was going to consider putting a new offer, and that the employer had said its commitment to negotiating might be reviewed because of the action (at [32], [63]); the Chief Commissioner saw a breakdown in one party's willingness to negotiate as a sign of an imminent deterioration in industrial relations (at [103]-[104]).

A union that says the employer is bargaining in bad faith is expected to use Division 2B against it. In the enforcement case that followed, a member of the Full Bench said the union should have sought orders against the employer instead of calling a stop work meeting in breach of an order (Registrar v SSTU [2008] WAIRC 00270 at [156]-[157]). Industrial action is covered in full in Disputes and industrial action.

Bargaining agents

A negotiating party may appoint a bargaining agent in writing, copied to the other party, and end the appointment the same way (s 42B(4)-(6)). A bargaining agent may advise and act in the bargaining despite the legal profession law (s 42B(7)), and is exempt from registering as an industrial agent (s 97J(4)(e)). A union and its officers are exempt anyway (s 97J(4)(a)-(b)).

Getting the Commission's help

  1. Section 42E orders. To help bargaining, the Commission may exercise its powers as if it were resolving an industrial matter, and may make orders and give directions to ensure the parties bargain in good faith or otherwise to help good faith bargaining, including an order that a party do or not do a particular thing (s 42E(1)-(3)). The application is on Form 1, with the grounds, served on each other negotiating party; no response is needed, and later applications in the same bargaining may be made in writing citing the first application's number (Commission Regulations reg 53).
  2. The limit. Section 42F means no order can require the parties to agree on content. Orders that track the s 42B(2) list (a meeting timetable, disclosure of specified information, a written response to the claims, facilities for delegates) are within the power.
  3. Compulsory conferences. Unions and employers also use s 44 conferences during bargaining, where the Commission can make orders to prevent industrial relations deteriorating (s 44(6)(ba)). The 2022 nurses' dispute began as an employer's s 44 application for help negotiating a replacement agreement (Registrar v Reah; ANF [2023] WAIRC 00299 at [2]). See Disputes and industrial action.
  4. Breach of the duty itself. A breach of s 42B(1) cannot be prosecuted before the Full Bench under s 84A (s 84A(1)(a) excludes it). The remedy is to seek orders; a s 42E order is then enforceable in its own right (ss 7, 83(1)).

When bargaining stalls: s 42G, s 42H and enterprise orders

Section 42G orderEnterprise order
What starts itThe parties have agreed some terms and jointly ask the Commission to settle the others (s 42G(1))A s 42H declaration that bargaining has ended, or no response or a refusal to a s 42 notice (s 42I(1))
ConsentYes: all negotiating parties sign the application (Commission Regulations reg 54A)No: one side applies
ResultThe terms become part of the registered industrial agreement (s 42G(5))A Commission-made instrument, not an agreement (s 42J)
AppealNone (s 42G(6))The ordinary s 49 appeal; nothing in ss 42I to 42K excludes it
What starts itSection 42G order: The parties have agreed some terms and jointly ask the Commission to settle the others (s 42G(1))
Enterprise order
A s 42H declaration that bargaining has ended, or no response or a refusal to a s 42 notice (s 42I(1))
ConsentSection 42G order: Yes: all negotiating parties sign the application (Commission Regulations reg 54A)
Enterprise order
No: one side applies
ResultSection 42G order: The terms become part of the registered industrial agreement (s 42G(5))
Enterprise order
A Commission-made instrument, not an agreement (s 42J)
AppealSection 42G order: None (s 42G(6))
Enterprise order
The ordinary s 49 appeal; nothing in ss 42I to 42K excludes it
Section 42G: the Commission settles the outstanding terms

Where the negotiating parties have agreed some but not all terms, they may apply to register the agreement with further terms to be specified and ask the Commission to order those terms (s 42G(1)). The Commission may order only on the matters the parties specified (s 42G(3)), may have regard to anything it considers relevant (s 42G(4)), and the terms become part of the agreement by force of the section (s 42G(5)); the agreement cannot be registered without them (s 41A(1)(b)). The application is signed by all negotiating parties, with each party's position on the unresolved matters (reg 54A).

In the local government arbitrations of 2024 and 2025 the Commission stated its approach (City of Albany [2024] WAIRC 00210 at [40]-[41]; City of Swan [2024] WAIRC 00989 at [5]-[7]; adopted in City of Greater Geraldton [2025] WAIRC 00224 at [11]):

  1. there is no onus in the usual sense, and the Commission decides according to equity and good conscience;
  2. any order needs a firm evidentiary basis;
  3. the discretion is broad, guided by the objects in s 6 and by s 26; and
  4. the State Wage Statement of Principles does not bind the Commission but can be relevant.

The Commission need not prefer either side's wages proposal, and may decide that other percentages are more appropriate ([2025] WAIRC 00224 at [310]-[311]). In one case it declined to impose automatic pay rises after the nominal expiry date, which it saw as a disincentive to bargaining ([2024] WAIRC 00210 at [172], [179], [181]).

Section 42H: a declaration that bargaining has ended

On a negotiating party's application, a single commissioner may declare that bargaining between it and another negotiating party has ended, if satisfied that (s 42H(1)):

  1. the applicant has bargained in good faith;
  2. bargaining between them has failed; and
  3. there is no reasonable prospect of agreement.

No appeal lies from the declaration (s 42H(2)), and bargaining between those parties ends (s 42L). The declaration opens the way to an enterprise order, which must be applied for within 21 days (s 42I(3)(a)). A declaration is available only if bargaining was initiated under s 42(1): see the first case study below.

Enterprise orders

An enterprise order can be sought (s 42I(1)-(3)):

  1. after a s 42H declaration, by the party in whose favour the declaration was made, within 21 days of it; or
  2. after no response or a refusal to a s 42 notice, by the initiating party, within 21 days after the end of the response period.

The order may deal with any matter that might otherwise be in an industrial agreement between the relevant parties, on terms the Commission considers fair and reasonable (s 42I(1)(c)-(d)). Conciliation continues alongside (s 42I(4)).

Once a gateway is met, the Commission asks whether there are matters that might otherwise have been in an agreement, and whether it is fair and reasonable to make the order in all the circumstances (Hanssen Pty Ltd v CFMEU [2004] WAIRC 10828 at [109], Full Bench; applied in [2026] WAIRC 00523 at [37]). The applicant carries the burden of showing the order should be made, and in the terms sought ([2004] WAIRC 10828 at [117]-[120]; LGRCEU v Shire of Gingin [2026] WAIRC 00815 at [8]). An employer that sought an enterprise order reducing or removing award penalty rates carried that burden, and failed to show any meaningful productivity or efficiency benefit (Kourtesis as trustee v United Workers Union [2023] WAIRC 00172 at [108]).

What an enterprise order can and cannot do
  1. Only the employer and the union that was the negotiating party, or the person who refused or failed to respond, can be specified in it (s 42J(5)). Other unions named in the notice cannot be brought in ([2026] WAIRC 00523, Schedule 1 at [25]-[30], [37]).
  2. It cannot reach employees outside the applicant union's eligibility rules, though one eligible employee is enough to enliven the power ([2026] WAIRC 00523, Schedule 1 at [31]; reasons at [25]-[26]).
  3. It binds only the specified employer and its employees in the callings named, prevails over a conflicting award or agreement, and is enforceable as if it were an award (s 42J(1), (3), (4)).
  4. It must state an expiry day no more than 2 years after it starts, can be varied only with the consent of everyone specified, and continues after expiry until replaced (s 42K(2), (3), (7)).
Public sector decisions

A s 42G order in an agreement that will bind a public sector entity, and an enterprise order binding one, are "public sector decisions". The Commission must then also consider the applicable Public Sector Wages Policy Statement and the State's and the entity's published financial position, in addition to the usual matters (s 26(2A)-(2C)). More is in The WA public sector.

Registering the agreement

The Commission must register

Where the parties apply, "the Commission must register the agreement as an industrial agreement", subject to s 41(3), s 41A and s 49N (s 41(2)). The Full Bench has held that Parliament gave the Commission "only the most minimal role": if the agreement answers s 41(1) and meets s 41A, there is no remaining power to refuse it, or to require changes, because of its content ([2023] WAIRC 00787 at [170]).

What s 41A requires

The agreement must:

  1. specify a nominal expiry date no later than 3 years after it comes into operation (s 41A(1)(a));
  2. include any term specified by a s 42G order (s 41A(1)(b));
  3. include an estimate of the number of employees bound on registration (s 41A(1)(c)); and
  4. where a union is a party, bind only employees who are members of, or eligible to join, that union (s 41A(2)).

In a multi-union agreement, each employee bound need only be a member or eligible member of at least one union party, so unions with partial or overlapping coverage may be parties to one agreement ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [194]-[195], [216]). In a single-union agreement, s 41A(2) stops an employer making an agreement with a union whose rules do not cover the workforce, to the exclusion of the union that does ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [181]-[183]).

The narrow power to require changes

Before registering, the Commission may require the parties to vary the agreement only "for the purpose of giving clear expression to the true intention of the parties" (s 41(3)). It is aimed at drafting errors, and cannot be used to add a party or to compel a matter not agreed ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [247]-[254]; [2023] WAIRC 00787 at [169]-[170]).

Other content rules
  1. A dispute settlement procedure is required: the parties must confer and try to resolve a question before taking it to the Commission (s 48A).
  2. Superannuation terms must let the employee nominate a complying fund (s 48B(2)).
  3. An agreement cannot give a union entry or inspection rights beyond Divisions 2F and 2G, except to set the notice period before entry (s 49Y). See Right of entry.
  4. A clause letting an employee and the employer vary the agreement by private arrangement, in the style of a federal individual flexibility arrangement, is inconsistent with the Act and would be invalid ([2023] WAIRC 00787 at [135], [144]-[147]). Facilitative provisions, which let the parties agree how a term applies within the instrument's limits, are not prohibited in themselves; a review of an award deleted its enterprise flexibility clause but kept them (Commission's Own Motion [2023] WAIRC 00836 at [101]-[108]).
Publication, service and objectors
  1. The application goes on Form 1 with a copy of the agreement signed by all parties and a statement summarising the changes it makes to pay and conditions (Commission Regulations reg 55(1)). A joint application is signed by each party and need not be served on them (reg 55(2A)-(2B)).
  2. The area and scope provisions must be published, unless the Chief Commissioner directs otherwise, and the application must be served on UnionsWA, the Chamber of Commerce and Industry and the Minister, before the hearing; the direction does not remove the need to serve (s 29A(1b), (2), (2A)-(2b)).
  3. The application is not listed for hearing until 14 days after publication unless the Commission directs otherwise (reg 55(3)).
  4. A union that is not a party may seek leave to intervene if it shows a sufficient interest, such as members in the workforce or a part in the bargaining (City of Canning v WASU [2025] WAIRC 00265 at [106]-[113], [140]-[143]). Its grounds are then confined to s 41 and s 41A ([2025] WAIRC 00265 at [148]; [2026] WAIRC 00005 at [253]).

What a registered agreement does

  1. Who it binds. All employees in the callings named, in the industry it applies to, employed by an employer party (or a member of an employers' organisation that is a party), and those employers, "and no other employee or employer" (s 41(4)). It operates in the area and for the term it specifies (s 41(5)).
  2. Back pay. It takes effect from registration, but the parties may agree that entitlements run from an earlier date, and once registered those terms bind (United Workers Union v Child and Adolescent Health Service [2023] WAIRC 00666 at [72]-[73]). Back pay to the old expiry date has to be written in.
  3. The award. To the extent the agreement is contrary to or inconsistent with an award, the agreement prevails unless it expressly says otherwise (s 41(9)). A clause saying the agreement is comprehensive and that differing award terms are inconsistent was held to be a valid use of s 41(9) ([2023] WAIRC 00787 at [101]-[104]). If award terms are meant to continue underneath, the agreement has to say so.
  4. No contracting out. An employer and employee may agree to better terms, but an agreement that purports to vary or cancel a term of an award or industrial agreement is void (s 114; [2023] WAIRC 00787 at [134]).
  5. Variation. Only by a further agreement between all the parties, or between the employer and the union so far as it concerns them (s 43(1)). An employee cannot apply to register or vary an agreement ([2023] WAIRC 00787 at [132]).
  6. Defunct agreements. The Commission may cancel an agreement under which no employee remains, or strike out a party that no longer carries on business, after a Registrar's inquiry and 30 days for objections (s 47).

Unions that are not parties, and no further claims clauses

A union that is not a party to a registered agreement cannot enforce it, be a party to a variation, apply under s 46 for its interpretation, or retire from it (TWU v City of Gosnells [2025] WAIRC 00961 at [130], Commission in Court Session). A union that wants to act for its members under an agreement needs to be a named party, with an eligibility rule that covers them.

Read moreShow less

Many WA agreements contain an undertaking that the parties will make no further claims during the term. The Full Bench has held:

  1. such undertakings are serious commitments, enforceable in their own right (Director General, Department of Justice v CSA [2025] WAIRC 00146 at [88]-[89]);
  2. any proposal by a party that would vary or improve on the outcomes in the agreement, in that party's interests, is a "further claim", and a s 44 application can be one (at [89], [92]); and
  3. the undertaking applies whether the union claims for all members, a class of them or a single member, unless the clause itself is narrower (at [93]-[95]).

Whether a particular claim is caught turns on the words of the clause. A dispute about how the employer exercises a discretion the agreement already gives it, or about what the agreement already means, is a different thing from a claim for something the agreement does not provide.

After the nominal expiry date

  1. The agreement keeps running. "Notwithstanding the expiry of the term", it continues in force for all parties except those who retire, until a new agreement or an award in substitution is made (s 41(6)). That includes its dispute procedure and any no further claims undertaking. Section 41(6) governs the period between expiry and a new agreement; it does not tie the parties to the terms for ever (City of Albany [2024] WAIRC 00210 at [184]).
  2. Retirement. At any time after expiry, or not more than 30 days before it, any party may file a notice of its intention to retire at the end of 30 days from filing; it then stops being a party (s 41(7)). The approved form is Form 10. Once the employer retires, the agreement no longer binds it, and its employees fall back to the award: the agreement is "effectively terminated" ([2024] WAIRC 00210 at [185]-[186]).
  3. A union party may retire too. If another union party stays in, the agreement continues for the employer and that union (s 41(6)).
  4. Replacement. A new registered agreement, or an award or enterprise order made in substitution, cancels the old agreement except so far as the new instrument saves its terms (s 41(8)). Bargaining for the replacement can start with a s 42 notice no earlier than 90 days before the old agreement's nominal expiry date (s 42(5)).
  5. Local governments. WA local governments moved into the state system on 1 January 2023. A Fair Work enterprise agreement that applied before then continued as a new State instrument under s 80BB until replaced ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [8]-[9]; [2023] WAIRC 00787 at [2]-[6]).

For unions and industrial officers

Send us the job. Get back cited research and a first draft.

Agreement interpretation, disputes, FWC applications and show-cause replies. Built on more than 400,000 Australian decisions, with a separate checking pass on every draft.

Decided cases

What the Commission and the courts decided.

Published decisions, retold in plain English from the decision itself. Each links to the full text. Lawcaptain did not act in these cases.

Application dismissedWestern Australian Industrial Relations Commission (Commissioner D J Matthews) · 8 August 2016

A letter that opened talks did not start bargaining under the Act, so no declaration could follow

A union wrote to the employer proposing to start talks on a replacement agreement and attached its claims. Months later it asked the Commission to declare that bargaining had ended. The employer said bargaining under the Act had never started.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. Application for a s 42H declaration dismissed (against the union): bargaining had never been initiated under s 42(1)

The union applied for a declaration under s 42H that bargaining for a replacement agreement for police auxiliary officers had ended ([1]). The employer accepted that there had been bargaining, but said it had not been under ss 42 to 42F ([2]).

The union relied on a letter proposing that discussions start immediately and attaching its list of claims ([8]). Read with the old agreement's coverage clause, it said, the letter made clear the types of employment, the area and the intended parties ([9]).

The Commissioner rejected that. The particulars in s 42(3) "must actually be expressly given", and it is not enough that they can be worked out from the surrounding circumstances ([10]). Compliance is easy because the form GFB 1 exists, and the parties must know exactly when a regime that can end in arbitration has been triggered ([11]). Bargaining outside s 42 is lawful (s 42(7)), which made certainty all the more important ([12]).

Because bargaining had not been initiated under s 42(1), no s 42H declaration could be made, and the application was dismissed ([13]).

In the decision's words: "I consider that section 42(3) Industrial Relations Act 1979 must be actually, and not substantially, complied with." ([10])

What it means for you

Every statutory lever in Division 2B, from good faith orders to an enterprise order, depends on a notice that states the types of employment, the area and the intended parties. Serve a completed GFB 1, even when talks are already under way.

Clause held invalidWestern Australian Industrial Relations Commission, Full Bench (Chief Commissioner Kenner, Commissioner Emmanuel, Commissioner Kucera) · 3 October 2023

A federal-style individual flexibility clause could not go into a WA agreement

When WA councils moved into the state system, one council's new agreement kept two clauses from the federal world: one excluding the awards, and one letting the council and an individual employee vary pay and conditions. The Commission referred both to the Full Bench.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. Questions of law answered: the exclusion of awards clause was valid; the individual flexibility clause would be invalid; the Commission has no power to require other variations before registration.

WA local government moved from the national system to the state system on 1 January 2023 ([1]). The council and two unions negotiated a new agreement and applied to register it under s 41 ([7]). Two clauses were controversial, and questions of law about them were referred to the Full Bench ([11]-[12]).

The first clause said the agreement excluded the awards and that any differing award entitlement was inconsistent with it. The Full Bench held that registering it would not be contrary to the Act, because s 41(9) lets an agreement prevail over an award ([173]).

The second clause let the employer and an employee make an individual flexibility arrangement varying overtime, penalty rates, allowances, leave loading and when work is done ([12]). Under the IR Act only the parties can make or vary an agreement, and an individual employee has no standing to do so ([131]-[132]). The clause let a person who was not a party vary the agreement, which was inconsistent with the Act's scheme, and it would be invalid if registered ([135], [144]-[147]).

The Full Bench also held that the Commission has no power to require changes before registration, other than to give clear expression to the parties' true intention under s 41(3): Parliament gave it "only the most minimal role" ([170]). It added that such clauses could lead employers into a breach of s 114 ([172]).

In the decision's words: "the IFA clause in this matter purports to enable persons who will not be parties to the industrial agreement, to vary it. This is ... inconsistent with the scheme for making and varying industrial agreements under the Act and is not permissible." ([144])

What it means for you

In the WA system the union is a necessary party to every collective agreement, and individual side-deals that change agreement terms do not survive. Check any clause carried over from a Fair Work agreement before signing.

Application dismissedWestern Australian Industrial Relations Commission (Senior Commissioner Cosentino) · 15 July 2026

A union left out of a council agreement sought an enterprise order of its own, and was refused

A union had bargained with a council alongside two other unions, but the council registered its new agreement with the other two only. The union served a bargaining notice, the council refused to bargain, and the union applied for an enterprise order.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. Application for an enterprise order dismissed (against the union): the primary relief was beyond power, and the alternative order was refused as not fair and reasonable.

The union took part in negotiations for a council's replacement agreement, but the council would not agree to it being a party, and registered the agreement with the other two unions ([1]-[2]). The union then gave the council a notice to initiate bargaining for an agreement mirroring the registered one. The council refused, and the union applied for an enterprise order under s 42I ([3]).

Its primary claim was an order naming all three unions. That failed on the first day: only the employer and the union that started bargaining (or the party that refused) can be specified, so the other unions could not be "roped in", and the order could not reach employees outside the applicant union's eligibility rules (Schedule 1 at [25]-[31], [37]).

Its alternative claim was an order in the same terms naming only it and the council, binding employees within its rules who were not members of the other two unions ([5]-[6]). The Senior Commissioner held that one eligible employee was enough to give the Commission power ([26]), and then asked whether it was fair and reasonable to make the order ([37]).

It was not. Coverage would shift whenever an employee joined or left another union, the council had no way of knowing members' union status, and asking employees was "impractical and objectionable" ([89]-[90]). The order would raise the council's risk of breaching the Act ([87]). The application was dismissed ([95]).

In the decision's words: "In the circumstances of this case described above it would be unfair and unreasonable to make an enterprise order and I decline to do so." ([95])

What it means for you

An enterprise order is limited to the union that started bargaining and the employees its rules cover, and it is discretionary even when the gateway is met. Coverage that turns on which union each employee belongs to will count against it.

Decided 15 July 2026. Check the WAIRC and Industrial Appeal Court lists for any appeal before relying on it.

Show more case studies (1)(1)Show fewer
Worked examples

How it plays out, step by step.

Illustrative example, not a real case

The letter that was not a s 42 notice

A council's agreement reaches its nominal expiry date in 60 days. An organiser emails the council's HR manager: "We wish to commence bargaining for a replacement agreement for our members", attaching the union's claims. Nothing else is sent.

Walk through itShow less
  1. Timing is fine. With an agreement in force, bargaining may be initiated no earlier than 90 days before its nominal expiry date (IR Act s 42(5)).
  2. The content is not. A s 42 notice must be accompanied by particulars of the types of employment to be covered, the area and the intended parties (s 42(3)). They must actually be given, not left to be worked out from the old agreement ([2016] WAIRC 00685 at [10]-[12]).
  3. As it stands, the email starts informal bargaining only (s 42(7)). None of the Division 2B levers (s 42E orders, a s 42H declaration, an enterprise order) is available.
  4. The fix is to serve a completed GFB 1 giving every particular (General Regulations reg 12), on every intended party, and to file a copy with the Registrar (reg 14(1)). The 21 days for a response then run from receipt (s 42A(1)).
What it means for you

Treat the GFB 1 as the start of the statutory process, even when talks have already begun informally.

Illustrative example, not a real case.

Illustrative example, not a real case

The employer that never answered

A union serves a completed GFB 1 on a private hospital operator that is a partnership, so in the state system. The operator receives it but says nothing.

Walk through itShow less
  1. The operator had 21 days from receiving the notice to say whether it would bargain (s 42A(1)). It may apply to extend that by up to 7 days, even after the 21 days have run, and an extension application stops any enterprise order application until it is decided (s 42A(2)-(3), (5)).
  2. If it still does not respond, the union may apply for an enterprise order within 21 days after the end of the response period (s 42I(1)(b), (3)(b)). Diarise both dates the day the notice is served.
  3. The order can specify only the operator and the union, and cannot reach employees outside the union's eligibility rules (s 42J(5), s 41A(2); [2026] WAIRC 00523, Schedule 1 at [25]-[31]).
  4. The union carries the burden of showing that an order should be made, and in the terms sought ([2004] WAIRC 10828 at [117]-[120]), so it needs evidence for each claim, not only proof that the operator refused to bargain.
  5. Any order lasts no more than 2 years and can be varied only with the consent of everyone specified in it (s 42K(2)-(3)).

Illustrative example, not a real case.

Questions

The things people ask.

Can we bargain without serving a s 42 notice?

Yes. Bargaining outside s 42 is lawful (s 42(7)). But the good faith duty, s 42E orders, s 42H declarations and enterprise orders attach only to bargaining started by a notice that complies with s 42(3) ([2016] WAIRC 00685 at [10]-[13]).

How early can we start bargaining for the next agreement?

Not earlier than 90 days before the current agreement's nominal expiry date (s 42(5)). If no agreement or enterprise order is in force, at any time (s 42(4)).

The employer has not answered our notice. What now?

It had 21 days from receiving the notice to say whether it would bargain (s 42A(1)), plus any extension of up to 7 days the Commission allows (s 42A(2)). If it did not answer, or refused, the union may apply for an enterprise order within 21 days after the end of that period (s 42I(1)(b), (3)(b)).

Does bargaining in good faith mean the employer has to agree to something?

No. No one has to agree to include or leave out any matter, or to make an agreement at all (s 42D). Good faith is about how the parties bargain: meeting, explaining positions, disclosing information, and not capriciously changing claims (s 42B(2)).

Is industrial action during bargaining a breach of good faith?

Not necessarily. The Commission may decide that it is, having regard to the circumstances (s 42B(3); [2008] WAIRC 00364 at [75]). See Disputes and industrial action.

Can the Commission refuse to register an agreement it does not like?

No. If the agreement answers s 41(1) and meets s 41A, the Commission must register it, and can require changes only to give clear expression to the parties' true intention (s 41(2)-(3); [2023] WAIRC 00787 at [170]).

Our union bargained but was not named in the agreement. Can we stop it being registered?

A union with a sufficient interest may seek leave to intervene ([2025] WAIRC 00265 at [106]-[113]), but its grounds are limited to s 41 and s 41A. Having bargained gives no right to be a party ([2026] WAIRC 00005 at [224]-[229]).

What happens to members' pay and conditions when the agreement expires?

The agreement keeps running until it is replaced (s 41(6)). But any party, including the employer, can file a notice to retire from it once it has expired, or up to 30 days before, and is no longer bound 30 days after filing (s 41(7)). If the employer retires, its employees fall back to the award ([2024] WAIRC 00210 at [185]-[186]).

Can the Commission just decide the pay rise if we cannot agree?

Only by consent: all negotiating parties must jointly ask for a s 42G order on the matters still in dispute, and there is no appeal from it (s 42G(1), (6)). Otherwise, an enterprise order needs a s 42H declaration or a refusal to bargain first (s 42I(1)).

Does a no further claims clause stop us filing a s 44 application for one member?

It may. The Full Bench has held that a claim to improve on the agreement is a further claim even if made for a single member, unless the clause is narrower ([2025] WAIRC 00146 at [92]-[95]). It turns on the clause's words.