Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) ss 29, 44, 83 and Part VIA

Members and their claims. The union can bring what a member cannot.

In the WA state system a union can refer almost any industrial matter for its members, while a member alone can bring only the claims the Act lists. The union can also enforce awards and agreements it is party to, get members' records, and act on freedom of association breaches.

28 daysafter the dismissal, for a member's own unfair dismissal referral (s 29(2)(a))
6 yearsafter the contravention, to apply to the Industrial Magistrates Court to enforce an award or agreement (s 82A)
21 daysafter a dismissal, for a federal unlawful termination application, which also reaches WA state employees (FW Act s 774)
A line drawing of a union organiser and a worker in a hi-vis vest sitting across a small table in a union office, looking through a thick folder of papers, with a filing box and a pot plant behind them

Key time limits

StepTimeSource
A member's own unfair dismissal referral28 days after the dismissal; a late referral needs the Commission to think it unfair not to accept itIR Act s 29(2)(a), (3)
Any referral relating to a public sector conditions-of-service decision, a s 78 or s 171 discipline decision, or a standards claim, whoever refers it28 days (from the decision, or after the agency resolution period for a standards claim)s 29(2)(b)-(d)
A union's claim about any other dismissalNo time limit is written in the Act; delay goes to the Commission's discretion. The Commission's Form 5 shows 28 days for a union referral of a public sector dismissals 29(2)(a); s 27(1)(a)
Enforcing an award, agreement or order, or a civil penalty provision, in the Industrial Magistrates Court6 years after the contraventions 82A
Employer's reply to a written request for a member's employment recordsBy the end of the next pay period after the request, or by the seventh day after its 49E(2)(d)
Paying a Part VIA penalty imposed on the unionImmediately, or within the period of up to 7 days the court allows, or the union's and members' rights are suspendeds 96F(2)-(4)
Federal unlawful termination application21 days after the termination took effect, or longer only in exceptional circumstancesFW Act s 774
A member's own unfair dismissal referralTime: 28 days after the dismissal; a late referral needs the Commission to think it unfair not to accept it
Source
IR Act s 29(2)(a), (3)
Any referral relating to a public sector conditions-of-service decision, a s 78 or s 171 discipline decision, or a standards claim, whoever refers itTime: 28 days (from the decision, or after the agency resolution period for a standards claim)
Source
s 29(2)(b)-(d)
A union's claim about any other dismissalTime: No time limit is written in the Act; delay goes to the Commission's discretion. The Commission's Form 5 shows 28 days for a union referral of a public sector dismissal
Source
s 29(2)(a); s 27(1)(a)
Enforcing an award, agreement or order, or a civil penalty provision, in the Industrial Magistrates CourtTime: 6 years after the contravention
Source
s 82A
Show all 7 rowsShow fewer
Employer's reply to a written request for a member's employment recordsTime: By the end of the next pay period after the request, or by the seventh day after it
Source
s 49E(2)(d)
Paying a Part VIA penalty imposed on the unionTime: Immediately, or within the period of up to 7 days the court allows, or the union's and members' rights are suspended
Source
s 96F(2)-(4)
Federal unlawful termination applicationTime: 21 days after the termination took effect, or longer only in exceptional circumstances
Source
FW Act s 774

The short version

In the WA state system, a member's union has wider standing than the member. In particular:

Read moreShow less
  1. the union can refer any industrial matter about members, or people eligible to be members, while a member can refer only the claims the Act lists (s 29(1));
  2. the union can bring a member's dismissal claim itself, with interim orders available, but the member and the union should not both run it;
  3. a union named as a party to an award or agreement can enforce it in the Industrial Magistrates Court, where unpaid amounts go to the employee and a penalty can go to the union (ss 83, 83A, 83F);
  4. a member, or the union holding the member's written authority, can require the employer to produce the member's employment records (s 49E);
  5. the Act prohibits discrimination for being, or not being, a union member, and binds the union as well as employers (Part VIA).

Words used on this page

  1. A "union" is an organisation of employees registered under the IR Act. A member is bound by its rules (s 61).
  2. To "refer" a matter is to start proceedings about it in the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) under s 29.
  3. A s 44 compulsory conference is the Commission's process for conciliating, and if necessary arbitrating, an industrial dispute. A union can apply for one (s 44(7)(a)(i)).
  4. An "entitlement provision" is a term of an award, industrial agreement or order, and certain MCE Act and LSL Act provisions, that can be enforced in the Industrial Magistrates Court (s 7(1)).

The union can refer what a member cannot

  1. An industrial matter may be referred "in any case" by an employer with a sufficient interest, by "an organisation in which persons to whom the industrial matter relates are eligible to be enrolled as members", or by the Minister (s 29(1)(a)).
  2. An individual may refer only what s 29(1)(b) to (l) and s 29(1a) give that person: for example unfair dismissal (s 29(1)(c)), denied contractual benefits (s 29(1)(d)), bullying (s 29(1)(e)), sexual harassment (s 29(1)(f)), and the public sector routes in s 29(1)(g) to (l).
  3. For a compulsory conference, s 44(7)(a) gives standing to "any organisation, association or employer" and the Minister, and to an individual only "in relation to a dispute about the person's entitlement to long service leave".
Read moreShow less

The Commission reads these words as meaning what they say. A teacher who was not dismissed could not challenge a note on his record himself, although his union could have brought the dispute: "Section 44 provides an organisation of employees ... with standing to bring matters on behalf of its members, that an individual does not have standing to bring" (Waterton v Director General, Department of Education [2023] WAIRC 00302 at [67]-[69]). On appeal in a health service case, the Full Bench said the same: an organisation "may refer an industrial matter to the Commission on behalf of an employee who is a member or is eligible to be a member", whereas an individual's referral right "is far more restricted" ([2026] WAIRC 00825 at [12]; under appeal to the Industrial Appeal Court, IAC 2/2026: as at 19 November 2026 the last published step was a programming order of 22 September 2026, [2026] WAIRC 00886, with no decision published).

Matters only the union can brings 7(1); s 29(1)(a)(ii)

An industrial matter is anything "affecting or relating or pertaining to the work, privileges, rights, or duties of employers or employees", including "the dismissal of or refusal to employ any person" and the relationship between employers and employees (s 7(1)). Matters a member cannot refer, but the union can, include:

  1. a suspension on full pay pending an investigation, and the way the investigation is run: the dispute "could only be by way of a fresh application ... by an organisation referred to in s 29(1)(a)(ii)" ([2026] WAIRC 00231 at [91], [97]);
  2. a reprimand, a warning, or a note on a personnel file, where no dismissal follows ([2023] WAIRC 00302 at [57], [68], [75]);
  3. a refusal to employ or re-employ a member: the "matter" referred is "the whole controversy" between the employer and the union, not the specific relief claimed (Director General, Department of Education v The State School Teachers' Union of WA (Incorporated) [2021] WAIRC 00025 at [51]-[52], Industrial Appeal Court);
  4. a transfer, a roster or duties change, or a process dispute affecting one member or a group, where no individual referral right exists.

Public sector matters, including the limit in s 23(3)(d) on regulating discipline, are covered in The WA public sector.

A dismissal: the member or the union

  1. A dismissed employee may refer an unfair dismissal claim personally within 28 days (s 29(1)(c), (2)(a)), or "that same claim may also be brought on behalf of the employee by their union for a compulsory conference under s 44 of the Act. In that case, the union does so as the applicant and therefore is the party to the proceeding" (The State School Teachers' Union of W.A. v Governing Council of North Metropolitan TAFE [2024] WAIRC 00191 at [84], Full Bench).
  2. The remedies are the same: on a claim of unfair dismissal brought under s 44 the Commission may make only orders authorised by s 23A or s 44 (s 23(3)(h)(i)). The s 44 route adds interim orders pending resolution of the claim (s 44(6)(bb)(ii)), which bind only the parties to the conference (s 44(6a)).
  3. "It is a question of who refers the industrial matter to the Commission, either the individual employee or their union" ([2024] WAIRC 00191 at [85]). If both start proceedings, the Commission may stop the duplication under s 27(1)(a) (at [86]).
Read moreShow less

Two points about that decision:

  1. it was decided on the former Public Sector Management Act s 78(2), replaced on 31 January 2025. No decision applying or distinguishing it on the routes in force since then was found;
  2. the employer appealed to the Industrial Appeal Court (IAC 3/2024). As at 19 November 2026 the last published step was programming orders of 31 May 2024 ([2024] WAIRC 00262), with no decision published.
A union settlement and the member's own claim[2022] WAIRC 00848

In one first-instance decision, a union settled its s 44 application about a member's demotion on terms the member agreed to, and the member took the benefit of the deal. Her later individual referral about the same decision was dismissed under s 27(1)(a): it would be "contrary to equity and good conscience for her to take the benefit of the Settlement Agreement and then deny that that deal binds her" (Smith v Minister for Corrective Services [2022] WAIRC 00848 at [40]-[43]). What mattered there was that the member agreed she was bound ([42]) and had taken the financial benefit ([40]). It is how the Commission dealt with those facts, not a general rule.

Limits that bind the union tooss 23(3)(d), 29AA
  1. Eligibility. The union must be one in which the persons concerned "are eligible to be enrolled as members" (s 29(1)(a)(ii)).
  2. Another Act's discipline scheme. The Commission must not regulate suspension, discipline or dismissal where another Act provides for the matter and for an appeal (s 23(3)(d)). Two first-instance decisions hold that this binds a union's s 44 application as much as a member's referral (Western Australian Prison Officers' Union of Workers v The Minister for Corrective Services [2013] WAIRC 00706 at [17]-[18]; United Professional Firefighters Union of Western Australia v Department of Fire and Emergency Services [2023] WAIRC 00399 at [49], [52]-[58]).
  3. The high-income bar. The Commission must not determine a claim of harsh, oppressive or unfair dismissal, or a denied contractual benefits claim, where no award or agreement applies and the salary exceeds the prescribed amount (s 29AA(3)-(4)). The words refer to the claim, not to who brings it.
  4. An earlier Fair Work application. The Commission must not determine an unfair dismissal claim if the employee has applied to the Fair Work Commission about the same termination, unless that application is withdrawn or rejected for want of jurisdiction (s 29AA(1)-(2)).
Time limits on a union's applications 29(2)-(3)
  1. Only s 29(2)(a) is tied to the member's own paragraph: "a referral under subsection (1)(c)".
  2. The other limits attach to the subject matter: "a referral relating to" a public sector conditions-of-service decision, a s 78 or s 171 discipline decision, or a standards claim must be made within 28 days (s 29(2)(b)-(d)). On their words they catch a union's s 29(1)(a)(ii) referral of those matters. Late referrals need s 29(3).
  3. Whether those limits also bind a union's s 44 application about the same decision is not settled. A judge of the Industrial Appeal Court treated a matter brought through a s 44 conference as distinct from a s 29(1) referral (Aurion Gold v Bilos [2004] WASCA 270 at [52]-[53], [57]-[58], EM Heenan J), while the Full Bench has described a union's s 44 application as the union referring the matter ([2024] WAIRC 00191 at [85]). No decision on the present s 29(2) was found.
  4. For a dismissal that is not a public sector s 78 or s 171 decision, no provision of the Act sets a time limit on the union's claim: s 29(2)(a) reaches only the member's own referral, and s 29(3) is tied to s 29(2). No decision holds this, but Industrial Appeal Court observations, not necessary to the decision, are to the same effect ([2004] WASCA 270 at [17], [56], [58]), and the Full Bench later recorded one of them (Public Transport Authority of Western Australia v The Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union of Employees, West Australian Branch [2017] WAIRC 00452 at [141]). Delay still goes to the Commission's discretion (s 27(1)(a)).

Enforcing awards and agreements in the Industrial Magistrates Court

Who may applys 83(1)

If a person contravenes an entitlement provision, any of these may apply to the Industrial Magistrates Court (s 83(1)):

  1. the Registrar or a deputy registrar, or an industrial inspector;
  2. "in the case of an award or industrial agreement, any organisation or association named as a party to it";
  3. an employer bound by it;
  4. a person who is a party to it or to whom it applies, or to whom an MCE Act or LSL Act entitlement provision applies.

No other route exists (s 83(3)). Being named as a party is the test for a union, not eligibility: a union that was not a party to the current agreement "has no standing to enforce the current industrial agreement" (Transport Workers' Union of Australia, Industrial Union of Workers, Western Australian Branch [2025] WAIRC 00961 at [130]). If the union is not a named party, the member brings the claim and the union acts as representative.

No paragraph of s 83(1) names a union for MCE Act or LSL Act entitlements as such. But where an award or agreement term is less favourable than a minimum condition, the minimum condition "is taken to be the term of the industrial instrument" (MCE Act s 5(2)), and may then be enforced as a provision of the instrument (MCE Act s 7(b)), which a union named as a party may do.

What the court can orderss 83, 83A, 83F
  1. A penalty of up to $93,000 for a body corporate and $18,000 for an individual, or $930,000 and $180,000 for a serious contravention, which means one the person knew of or was reckless about (s 83(4A); s 83EA(2)).
  2. Orders to prevent further contravention, including interim orders pending the final hearing (s 83(5)-(7)).
  3. Where an employee was not paid an entitlement, the court must order the amount underpaid to be paid to the employee, for up to 6 years before the proceedings began (s 83A(1)-(2)). The money goes to the employee, not the claimant: the court is "not permitted" to order the underpaid amounts paid to the claimant, even by consent (Aplin v Elliott t/a Leeson Plumbing [2025] WAIRC 00779 at [84]-[86], an inspector's case).
  4. A penalty, or part of it, may be ordered paid to a person directly affected, to the applicant, or to the Treasurer (s 83F(2)).
  5. A person "involved in" a contravention, by aiding, inducing, being knowingly concerned in or conspiring, is taken to contravene it, so a director or manager can be joined (s 83(2)-(2A)).
Other claims the union can bring theress 83B, 83E
  1. Enforcing an unfair dismissal order. If an employer does not comply with a reinstatement, re-employment or compensation order, "an organisation of employees in which the employee ... is eligible to be enrolled as a member" may apply, with no fee (s 83B(1)-(2)). Here eligibility, not being a party, is the test.
  2. Civil penalty provisions. For breaches such as the records and pay slip duties (ss 49D, 49DA, 49E), obstructing entry (s 49M) and damaging action (s 97A), an application may be made by a person directly affected or by "an organisation or association of which" that person is a member (s 83E(6)). The civil standard of proof applies (s 83E(8)).
Time, costs, burden and appealss 82A, 83C, 83EB, 84
  1. An application under s 83, s 83B or s 83E must be made within 6 years after the contravention (s 82A).
  2. Costs for a lawyer or agent are not awarded to either side unless the court finds a serious contravention or the proceedings were brought or defended frivolously or vexatiously (s 83C(2); s 83E(12)).
  3. Where the employer was required to make, keep or make available a record, or give a pay slip, about the matter and did not, it bears the burden of disproving the allegation, unless it has a reasonable excuse (s 83EB).
  4. An appeal from the court in its IR Act jurisdiction goes to the Full Bench (s 84).

Which forum for which goal

GoalForumUnion standing
Recover underpaid award or agreement wages, and a penaltyIndustrial Magistrates Court, ss 83, 83AIf named as a party (s 83(1)(c))
Settle what an award or agreement meansWAIRC, s 46 interpretationIf bound by it ([2025] WAIRC 00961 at [130]); see Awards and orders
A dispute that is not yet a contravention, or needs a future-looking orderWAIRC, s 44 conferenceAny organisation (s 44(7)(a)(i))
Enforce a reinstatement or compensation orderIndustrial Magistrates Court, s 83BIf the employee is eligible to be a member
A penalty for records, pay slip, entry or damaging action breachesIndustrial Magistrates Court, s 83EIf a directly affected person is a member, or the union is itself affected
Recover underpaid award or agreement wages, and a penaltyForum: Industrial Magistrates Court, ss 83, 83A
Union standing
If named as a party (s 83(1)(c))
Settle what an award or agreement meansForum: WAIRC, s 46 interpretation
Union standing
If bound by it ([2025] WAIRC 00961 at [130]); see Awards and orders
A dispute that is not yet a contravention, or needs a future-looking orderForum: WAIRC, s 44 conference
Union standing
Any organisation (s 44(7)(a)(i))
Enforce a reinstatement or compensation orderForum: Industrial Magistrates Court, s 83B
Union standing
If the employee is eligible to be a member
A penalty for records, pay slip, entry or damaging action breachesForum: Industrial Magistrates Court, s 83E
Union standing
If a directly affected person is a member, or the union is itself affected

Getting a member's employment records

  1. With the member's written authority. "An employer, on written request by a relevant person, must (a) produce to the person the employment records relating to an employee; and (b) let the person inspect the employment records" (s 49E(1)). A relevant person includes "a person authorised in writing by the employee" (s 49E(4)), such as a union official holding the member's signed authority.
  2. The duty survives the end of employment and of the industrial instrument, and includes letting the person enter the premises to inspect and copy (s 49E(2)(a)-(c)). It must be met by the end of the next pay period after the request, or by the seventh day after it (s 49E(2)(d)). Refusal is a civil penalty contravention (s 49F).
  3. Without the member's authority. A union official holding a right of entry permit may enter to investigate a suspected breach and require relevant records, on notice. See Right of entry.
When records are not producedss 83A(2)(b), 83EB, 102
  1. In s 83 proceedings, the burden shifts to the employer on a matter it was required to keep a record about and did not (s 83EB).
  2. An underpayment order may reach back further than 6 years where the employer has contravened s 102(1)(a) or (b) by failing, "being lawfully required to do so", to produce or allow examination of a record relevant to the proceedings; the order may then cover a period up to 6 years before "that failure" (s 83A(2)(b)).
  3. Applied at first instance: an industrial inspector's notices to produce went unanswered months before the claim began, and the claim period ran from 6 years before the failure, not 6 years before the claim (Dixon v Karakuyu [2025] WAIRC 00039 at [6]-[7], [18]-[21], [605]-[614]). A penalty may still be imposed only within the 6-year limit in s 82A (at [49]-[50]).
  4. Whether an unanswered s 49E request, made by the member or a person the member authorised, is a lawful requirement for s 102(1)(a), so that it lifts the 6-year cap, has not been decided. The definitions in s 7(1) and s 102(4)-(5) point both ways.

Freedom of association

One of the IR Act's objects is "to promote the principles of freedom of association and the right to organise" (s 6(ab)). It is the freedom "to choose whether or not they wish to join a union", not to choose which union "regardless of a union's eligibility rules" ([2025] WAIRC 00961 at [138]-[139]). The WA system has no general protections regime like the federal one; its protections are below.

No compulsion or preferencess 7(1), 23(3), 96B
  1. Compulsion to join, preference in employment and refusing employment because of membership are not industrial matters, and the Commission must not make an award or order providing for them (s 7(1); s 23(3)(e)-(f)). Collecting union subscriptions with the employee's agreement is an industrial matter, so a union can take a payroll deductions dispute to the Commission (s 7(1)).
  2. An award, industrial agreement, order or "any arrangement between persons relating to employment" must not require a person to join, stay in, leave or not join a union, or confer preferential employment because of membership; a contrary requirement "is of no effect" (s 96B(1), (3)).
The offences, which bind unions tooss 96C-96G
  1. Treating a person less or more favourably in relation to a contract of employment or for services according to whether they are, or will become or cease to be, a member or officer of a union (s 96C(1)).
  2. "A person, including an organisation of employees", must not, because a worker is or is not a member or officer, refuse to employ them, intimidate or prejudice them, induce an employer to prejudice them, or hinder their employment or promotion (s 96D(1)-(2), (4)).
  3. "A person, including an organisation of employees", must not threaten to refuse to deal with a person, or to interfere with their trade, because of non-membership, and must not take or threaten industrial action to coerce an employer to do so or "to join an organisation of employees" (s 96E).

Each offence carries a fine of $400 to $5,000 for an individual, and $1,000 to $10,000 plus $500 a day for anyone else (ss 96C-96E); the minimums cannot be reduced (s 96F(1)). For a union the most serious consequence is this: if it does not pay a Part VIA penalty within the time allowed, its rights and its members' rights are suspended until it pays, so that no proceeding may be started by or for them and no award or order may be made for their benefit (s 96F(2)-(4)). An officer or member's offence is also the union's unless it shows it took all reasonable steps to prevent it (s 96G).

Proof and prosecutionss 96I, 104
  1. If a person was treated differently while a member or officer, or not, the s 96C(1) offence is taken to be proved unless the contrary is shown; the same applies to s 96D (s 96I(1)-(2)). For s 96E, once the other facts are proved, the accused must prove the action was not taken for that reason or with that intent (s 96I(3)).
  2. Only an industrial magistrate's court hears the charge, as a court of summary jurisdiction (ss 83D(1), (3), 81CA(5)).
  3. A person the Minister authorises, an industrial inspector or the Registrar may prosecute. Anyone else may too, but the charge "must be dismissed for want of prosecution unless the court is satisfied that the prosecutor has been affected by the conduct giving rise to the offence" (s 104(5)). Whether a union is "affected" by conduct aimed at its members, or at non-members, has not been decided; no decision applying s 104(5) was found.
  4. The Part VIA prosecutions found (1996 to 2003) were brought by industrial inspectors and other officers of the State department responsible for industrial relations.
Civil orders and damaging actionss 96J, 96L, 97A
  1. A person who claims to have been affected by a breach of s 96C, 96D or 96E may apply to the Industrial Magistrates Court for an order to do or stop doing something, to prevent further breaches. Appeal lies to the Industrial Appeal Court (s 96J, s 96K).
  2. On conviction, an employer may be ordered to reinstate the complainant and pay compensation (s 96L(1)).
  3. An employer must not take damaging action, such as dismissal or disadvantage, against an employee because the employee "is able to make an employment-related inquiry or complaint" to the employer or another person; once the action is proved, the employer must prove its reason was not that (s 97A(1)-(2)). It is a civil penalty provision, so a union of which the affected employee is a member may apply (s 83E(6)(b)).

Three points about s 97A and the union:

  1. A complaint the member makes to the union is within the words "the employer or another person". On a strike-out application, the Industrial Magistrates Court read the extrinsic material as protecting complaints "to their employer; a union; a regulator; or other body" (Brady v Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development [2024] WAIRC 00473 at [68], [71]).
  2. Asking a union representative how to lodge a complaint is not itself a complaint; it "merely requests of a third party the process for lodging a complaint" (Gavril v State of Western Australia [2026] WAIRC 00031 at [211]-[213]; under appeal to the Full Bench, FBA 3 and FBA 14 of 2026, joined: as at 19 November 2026 the Full Bench had ordered that the appeals be decided on the written submissions ([2026] WAIRC 00869, 17 September 2026), and no decision on them had been published).
  3. Whether a complaint the union makes to the employer on the member's behalf is the member's own complaint for s 97A has not been decided. Unlike the Fair Work Act (s 340(2)), the IR Act has no separate protection for action taken because someone else exercised a right for the employee.
The federal overlay: unlawful terminationFW Act ss 770-774
  1. In FW Act Part 6-4, "employee and employer have their ordinary meanings" (s 770), so the unlawful termination protections reach WA state system employees.
  2. An employer must not terminate employment for reasons including "trade union membership or participation in trade union activities", non-membership, or acting as a representative of employees (s 772(1)(b)-(d)). The employee, or "an industrial association that is entitled to represent the industrial interests of an employee", may apply to the Fair Work Commission within 21 days (ss 773, 774).
  3. A dismissed person must not make more than one of the applications listed in FW Act ss 726 to 732, which include an application under a State law (s 725). And the WAIRC must not determine an unfair dismissal claim while a Fair Work Commission application about the same termination is on foot (IR Act s 29AA(1)-(2)). So the forum has to be chosen early: 21 days federally, 28 days for the member in WA.

For unions and industrial officers

Send us the job. Get back cited research and a first draft.

Agreement interpretation, disputes, FWC applications and show-cause replies. Built on more than 400,000 Australian decisions, with a separate checking pass on every draft.

Decided cases

What the Commission and the courts decided.

Published decisions, retold in plain English from the decision itself. Each links to the full text. Lawcaptain did not act in these cases.

No jurisdiction: claim dismissedWestern Australian Industrial Relations Commission (Commissioner Tsang) · 29 May 2023

A relief teacher could not challenge a note on his record himself; his union could have

After a disciplinary process, a former relief teacher was reprimanded and his record was endorsed so that he could not be re-employed without the department's prior reference. He referred the flag to the Commission himself. The question was whether he could.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. Application dismissed: the Commission had no jurisdiction to hear the teacher's own referral about the flag.

After a disciplinary process about one day of relief teaching, the department found breaches of discipline and reprimanded him. Separately, it endorsed his employment record: he was not to be permitted future employment with the department without prior reference to its Director, Standards and Integrity. The department said the endorsement was not a disciplinary measure and not a refusal to re-employ.

He referred the endorsement to the Commission himself. The department objected that he had no standing.

The Commission agreed with the department. The individual referral rights in s 29(1) are limited, the flag was not a dismissal, and s 29(1)(c) could not be read as covering any harsh, oppressive or unfair treatment ([67]-[69], [73]). The teacher's union could have brought the dispute under s 44.

Any unreasonable result was, the Commission said, "a matter for parliament" ([76]).

In the decision's words: "Section 44 provides an organisation of employees, such as the SSTU, with standing to bring matters on behalf of its members, that an individual does not have standing to bring." (at [68])

What it means for you

A reprimand, a warning or a flag on a file, without a dismissal, is usually not something a member can take to the Commission alone. The union can, under s 29(1)(a)(ii) or s 44, if it is asked in time.

Won by the union on appealWAIRC Full Bench (Chief Commissioner Kenner, Senior Commissioner Cosentino, Commissioner Kucera) · 6 May 2024

"All roads lead to the Commission": a union could run a dismissed lecturer's case itself

A TAFE lecturer was dismissed. His union applied under s 44 for interim reinstatement and reinstatement. The college said the union could not, because the lecturer had his own statutory route.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. Appeal upheld: the order dismissing the union's s 44 application was quashed. The dismissal itself was not decided. The college has appealed to the Industrial Appeal Court (IAC 3/2024), undecided as at 19 November 2026.

In late September 2023 the union applied under s 44 on behalf of a member, a lecturer the college had dismissed. It sought an interim reinstatement order under s 44(6)(bb)(ii), and reinstatement or re-employment.

The college said the Commission had no power, because the lecturer could himself refer the matter under the Public Sector Management Act s 78(2), and that was an "appeal" which engaged the limit in s 23(3)(d). The Commission dismissed the union's application, and the union appealed.

The Full Bench held that the same claim may be brought by the employee or by the union, which then "is the party to the proceeding" ([84]). "It is a question of who refers the industrial matter to the Commission, either the individual employee or their union" ([85]). Unlike a case of two separate, competing tribunals, here "all roads lead to the Commission" ([85]); any duplication can be dealt with under s 27(1)(a) ([86]). Section 23(3)(d) was not engaged, and the order was quashed ([91]).

The decision was on the former s 78(2), replaced on 31 January 2025. The college appealed to the Industrial Appeal Court (IAC 3/2024); as at 19 November 2026 the last published step was programming orders of 31 May 2024, with no decision published.

What it means for you

In the WA system a union can run a member's dismissal claim in its own name under s 44, with interim orders available. The union and the member should agree early which of them brings it, so that only one claim runs.

Member's referral dismissedWestern Australian Industrial Relations Commission (Commissioner Emmanuel) · 16 December 2022

A prison officer agreed to her union's settlement and took its benefit, then referred the same decision herself: dismissed

A prison officer was demoted for a breach of discipline. Her union challenged it under s 44 and settled, with her agreement. She then referred the same decision herself.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. The employer's s 27(1)(a) application was upheld and the member's own referral was dismissed.

The officer was demoted from senior officer to prison officer by way of disciplinary action. Her union brought a s 44 application challenging the finding and the penalty. After conciliation it was resolved: the demotion and findings remained, she would sign a letter acknowledging the findings and complete an online module, and she would not act in a higher role until 6 November 2021, other than at minimum security prisons ([26]). The union's lawyer wrote that she and the union agreed to resolve it on those terms.

She later referred the same disciplinary decision to the Commission herself. The Minister asked for it to be dismissed under s 27(1)(a), and she argued that the settlement did not bind her.

The Commission found that she had agreed she was bound ([42]) and had taken the financial benefit of the settlement ([40]). It would be "contrary to equity and good conscience for her to take the benefit of the Settlement Agreement and then deny that that deal binds her", and allowing the claim would discourage settlement at s 44 conferences ([40]-[43]).

What it means for you

When a union settles a member's matter, the settlement may end the member's own claim if the member agreed to it and took its benefit. A union settling a member's matter can record the member's written agreement, and say in the terms whether the member's own rights survive.

Union found guiltyIndustrial Magistrates Court (Industrial Magistrate Brown) · 22 August 2003

"Sign the boys up" or work stops: an officer's threat made the union guilty too

At a demolition site, a union officer told a contractor that work would stop unless his workers joined the union. The officer was convicted. The department then charged the union itself.

Read the full storyShow less

Result. Charge against the union proved under ss 96E(1)(b) and 96G(2), after its officer had been convicted of the same threat.

In January 2002 a demolition company was pulling down two old grandstands at a Perth sports ground. A union officer came on site and, on the evidence accepted in his own trial, told the company's director that work would stop unless the workers joined the union. The director paid for himself and four employees to join, and work continued ([2002] WAIRC 06826).

The officer was convicted in October 2002 of threatening that the company's occupation would be interfered with because its workers were not members of a union, contrary to s 96E(1)(b) ([2002] WAIRC 06826).

An officer of the department then charged the union under s 96E(1)(b) and s 96G(2). Section 96G(2) makes a union guilty of its officer's or member's Part VIA offence unless it proves it took all reasonable steps to prevent it. The union called no evidence, and the only issue its counsel raised was whether the person convicted was the same person as the union's officer. The court found that he was the union's assistant secretary at the time, and convicted the union.

What it means for you

In the WA system, pressure to join a union, backed by a threat to stop work, is an offence, and an officer's offence is the union's offence unless the union shows it took all reasonable steps to prevent it. Recruitment by persuasion is lawful; recruitment by threat is not.

Show more case studies (2)(2)Show fewer
Worked examples

How it plays out, step by step.

Illustrative example, not a real case

A member gets a written warning and a note on her file

A member employed by a WA local government receives a written warning and a note on her personnel file after a complaint. She is not dismissed, and she says the process was unfair.

Walk through itShow less
  1. Can she refer it herself? Not on the authorities: a warning or a file note without a dismissal is not among the individual referral rights in s 29(1)(b) to (l) ([2023] WAIRC 00302 at [67]-[69], [73]).
  2. Can the union? Yes, if she is eligible to be a member: the union may refer the industrial matter under s 29(1)(a)(ii), or apply for a s 44 conference (s 44(7)(a)(i)).
  3. The instrument. If the award or agreement has a disciplinary or grievance procedure, the dispute can be framed around whether it was followed.
  4. Timing. No time limit is written for a union's s 44 application about a warning, but delay goes to the Commission's discretion (s 27(1)(a)).
  5. Settlement. If the matter settles, a union in this position may record the member's written agreement to the terms ([2022] WAIRC 00848 at [40]-[43]).
Illustrative example, not a real case

Several members have been underpaid under an industrial agreement

A union finds that a private employer in the state system has underpaid casual loadings to eight members for three years under a registered industrial agreement.

Walk through itShow less
  1. Is the union a named party to the agreement? If yes, it may apply to the Industrial Magistrates Court itself (s 83(1)(c)). If not, each member applies and the union represents them ([2025] WAIRC 00961 at [130]).
  2. Get the records. With each member's written authority, the union can require the employer to produce the records by the next pay period or the seventh day (s 49E). If records were not kept, the employer bears the burden of disproving the claim (s 83EB).
  3. Time. The claim must be made within 6 years of each contravention (s 82A), so three years of underpayment is within time.
  4. Orders. The court must order the underpaid amounts paid to the employees, not the union (s 83A; [2025] WAIRC 00779 at [84]-[86]). A penalty may be ordered paid to the union as applicant (s 83F(2)).
  5. If a minimum condition is better than the agreement term, the MCE Act condition is taken to be a term of the agreement and can be enforced as one (MCE Act ss 5(2), 7(b)).
Questions

The things people ask.

Can a WA state union take a member's grievance to the Commission when the member cannot?

Yes. A union in which the people concerned are eligible to be members may refer any industrial matter (s 29(1)(a)(ii)) or apply for a s 44 conference (s 44(7)(a)(i)). A member alone can refer only the claims s 29(1)(b) to (l) and s 29(1a) list ([2023] WAIRC 00302 at [67]-[69]).

Should the member or the union bring a dismissal claim?

Either can, but not both. The member can refer an unfair dismissal claim within 28 days (s 29(1)(c), (2)(a)); the union can bring the same claim under s 44, as the party, with interim orders available ([2024] WAIRC 00191 at [84]-[86]). That decision is under appeal to the Industrial Appeal Court (IAC 3/2024), with no decision published as at 19 November 2026.

Is there a time limit for a union's dismissal claim?

For a public sector s 78 or s 171 decision, the Act says a referral relating to it must be made within 28 days of the decision (s 29(2)(c)); whether that also binds a union's s 44 application has not been decided. For other dismissals no provision of the Act sets a time limit on the union's claim, and no decision holds otherwise; delay goes to the Commission's discretion (s 27(1)(a)), and the Commission's Form 5 shows 28 days for a public sector dismissal.

Does a union settlement stop the member suing?

It can. In one first-instance decision, a member who agreed to her union's s 44 settlement and took its benefit had her own later claim dismissed ([2022] WAIRC 00848 at [40]-[43]). It depends on the facts, so the terms should say whether the member's own rights survive.

Can the union recover underpayments in the Industrial Magistrates Court?

If it is named as a party to the award or agreement, yes (s 83(1)(c)). Otherwise the member applies. The money is ordered paid to the employee (s 83A), and a penalty may be ordered paid to the applicant (s 83F(2)).

How can the union get a member's pay records?

With the member's written authority, the union is a "relevant person" who can require the employer to produce and let it inspect the records (s 49E(1), (4)). The employer must comply by the end of the next pay period or the seventh day after the request (s 49E(2)(d)).

Can a union agreement give union members preference?

No. An award, agreement, order or arrangement must not require membership or give preferential employment because of membership, and any such term is of no effect (s 96B).

Can a union be prosecuted for what an organiser says on site?

Yes. A union is guilty of its officer's or member's Part VIA offence unless it proves it took all reasonable steps to prevent it (s 96G). A union has been convicted on that basis ([2003] WAIRC 09129). If it does not pay a Part VIA penalty in time, its rights and its members' rights are suspended (s 96F(2)-(4)).

Is a member protected for complaining to the union?

An employer must not take damaging action against an employee because the employee is able to make an employment-related inquiry or complaint to the employer or another person (s 97A(1)). A complaint to a union has been read as within those words at first instance ([2024] WAIRC 00473 at [68], [71]). Whether the union's own complaint on the member's behalf counts has not been decided.

Can a WA state employee dismissed for union activity go to the Fair Work Commission?

Yes. The federal unlawful termination provisions apply to state system employees, within 21 days (FW Act ss 770, 772, 774). The employee generally cannot also pursue a WA unfair dismissal claim for the same dismissal (FW Act s 725; IR Act s 29AA(1)-(2)).