Home Learn Unfair Dismissal

Constructive dismissal: when you are forced to resign

Constructive dismissal is a resignation that the law treats as a dismissal, because your employer's conduct left you no real choice but to quit. It can support an unfair dismissal or general protections claim, the same as being sacked. But the bar is high, and many people who resign for good reasons are found to have resigned voluntarily. This page explains the test, how the Fair Work Commission has decided common situations, and what to do before you resign.

Still employed? You have more options now than after you resign. Already resigned? The 21-day limit may be running.

Short answers

What is constructive dismissal?

Short answer: you resigned, but your employer's conduct forced you to. The Fair Work Act says you are dismissed if you "resigned ... but [were] forced to do so because of conduct, or a course of conduct, engaged in by" the employer (s 386(1)(b)).

I resigned because of bullying. Can I still make a claim?

Short answer: possibly, but only if your employer's conduct, including a failure to act on the bullying, left you no effective or real choice but to resign. A resignation that was reasonable is not enough.

How long do I have?

Short answer: within 21 days after the day your resignation took effect, for unfair dismissal and for general protections. If you worked out notice, that is usually your last day. In the WA state system it is 28 days.

The test: when a resignation counts as a dismissal

Under s 386(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a resignation is a dismissal if you were forced to resign because of your employer's conduct or course of conduct. "Conduct" includes an omission (s 12), so a failure to act can count. In Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 the Full Bench said the provision has two conditions:

  1. You were forced. You had "no effective or real choice but to resign" (at [40]). That does not mean resignation had to be the only thing you could possibly have done (at [40]-[41]).
  2. Your employer's conduct caused it. Feeling you had to leave is not enough. That situation "must have arisen because of conduct, or a course of conduct, engaged in by the employer" (at [44]).

The Commission looks at your employer's conduct objectively. The long-standing test, from O'Meara v Stanley Works Pty Ltd [2006] AIRC 496 at [23] and adopted under the Fair Work Act in Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279 at [19], asks whether the employer's conduct was intended to bring the employment to an end, or was "of such a nature that resignation was the probable result", or left the employee "no effective or real choice but to resign".

Why the bar is high

In Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279, an employee resigned after months of wages paid a day or two late and no superannuation. The Full Bench accepted that late wages can sometimes force a resignation (at [21]), and that her resignation was "a possible and foreseeable result" and "in many respects a reasonable response". But that was not enough. Given the other ways she could have pursued her complaints, resignation was not the probable result of the employer's conduct (at [24]).

Two points follow:

Resigning in the heat of the moment

Words of resignation said in anger or distress may not be a real resignation if you could not reasonably be understood to mean them. If your employer simply treats it as ending your job instead of checking with you after a reasonable time, that can be a termination at the employer's initiative under s 386(1)(a) (Bupa Aged Care Australia Pty Ltd v Tavassoli [2017] FWCFB 3941 at [47]).

The question is whether a reasonable person in your employer's position would have understood you truly intended to resign. Withdrawing it within a reasonable time points against a real resignation; letting time pass points the other way (Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 at [64]-[66]).

Common situations and how they were decided

SituationDecisionForced?
Wages mostly unpaid for monthsHobbs v Achilleus Taxation Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 2907Yes
Wages a day or two late, no superBruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279No
No pay while a workers compensation claim was assessedCommonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82No
Isolated after workplace conflict, disciplinary reply due the day sick leave endedAustralian Hearing v Peary [2009] AIRCFB 680Yes
One serious bullying incident, employer took stepsNoble v Smiling Samoyed Pty Ltd [2023] FWCFB 257No
Told the decision was made, offered a managed resignationLipa Pharmaceuticals Ltd v Jarouche [2023] FWCFB 101Yes
Resign or the police will be calledMohazab v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd (No 2) [1995] IRCA 645Yes

Unpaid or late wages

In Hobbs v Achilleus Taxation Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 2907, the employee had received about $3,570 of more than $11,600 earned over several months and his messages about it got no real answer. The Commission found he "could not be expected to continue to provide services to his employer in a situation where the employer did not pay his wages" (at [12]). The employer did not appear, and a Full Bench refused it permission to appeal.

The pay must stop because of your employer. In Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82, the employee had used all his leave and was waiting on a workers compensation claim. That was a matter for Comcare, a separate body, not conduct of the employer (at [48]-[50], [79]).

Demotion or a pay cut

If you stay on after a demotion, a demotion is not a dismissal if it involves no significant reduction in your pay or duties and you remain employed (s 386(2)(c)). In NSW Trains v James [2022] FWCFB 55, a majority of a five-member Full Bench held that this is only an exclusion: a demoted employee who stays is dismissed only if their employment was terminated on the employer's initiative under s 386(1)(a) (at [32]-[34]). That can happen where:

  1. the demotion repudiated the contract;
  2. the employee accepted the repudiation; and
  3. they kept working under a new contract (at [45]).

A demotion the enterprise agreement allowed was not a repudiation (at [122]-[123]).

If you resign because of an unauthorised demotion or pay cut, the forced resignation test applies. Conduct that can force a resignation includes the employer breaching or renouncing a term of your contract so that it is "intolerable or unreasonable for the employee to continue" (Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 at [45]).

Bullying and harassment

In Australian Hearing v Peary [2009] AIRCFB 680, after conflict with co-workers, the employee was moved to another office, cut off from her team and given limited work, with "little or no prospect of the situation altering" (at [35]). She was then told to answer a disciplinary charge the day her sick leave expired. A finding that she was forced to resign was upheld (at [38]). It was decided under the predecessor provision, which was in similar terms.

In Noble v Smiling Samoyed Pty Ltd [2023] FWCFB 257, a manager she worked under in the bar confronted the employee in a serious and threatening incident. The employer's response was imperfect, but it warned the manager, arranged conflict resolution and an apology, and offered to keep them apart. She had other choices, so she was not forced, though resigning was not unreasonable (at [31]-[37]). The Full Bench found no error (at [57]).

Resign or be sacked

Being told to resign in the face of a threatened or impending dismissal is the classic forced resignation (Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279 at [12], quoting the Explanatory Memorandum; Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 at [45]). In Lipa Pharmaceuticals Ltd v Jarouche [2023] FWCFB 101, a manager told an employee he had made his decision, suggested she announce her resignation, and let her collect her things. The Full Bench held it was "beyond doubt" she was forced to resign (at [18]-[20]).

An ultimatum during an investigation

In Mohazab v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd (No 2) [1995] IRCA 645, a manager suspected of dishonesty over a missing item of stock was told during an interview to resign or the police would be "called in". The Full Court held this was a termination at the employer's initiative: "When an employee has no effective or real choice but to resign it can hardly be said that the termination of her or his employment is truly at the employee's initiative." See also Show cause letter: how to respond.

A resignation you negotiated

Resigning as part of a deal you negotiated and accepted, on advice, is usually voluntary, even if you would rather not have (Fedec v Minister for Corrective Services [2017] WAIRC 00828 at [44]-[46], a WA Full Bench decision). But negotiating the terms of an exit your employer has already decided on does not make it voluntary (Lipa Pharmaceuticals Ltd v Jarouche [2023] FWCFB 101 at [20]). If you are offered a payment to leave, see deed of release.

General protections since 7 July 2026

A forced resignation can also found a general protections claim, where you say you were pushed out for an unlawful reason, such as a complaint or an illness. Since 7 July 2026 you can apply to the Commission if you allege you were dismissed for an unlawful reason (s 365). The Commission need not decide whether you were dismissed before it starts dealing with the dispute (s 368(1A)), so an employer saying "you resigned" no longer stops the conference.

If the dispute goes to court and you rely on the dismissal as the adverse action, you will still have to prove the resignation was forced. You can bring only one claim about the ending of your job (s 725). See General protections claims since 7 July 2026.

Unfair dismissal did not change. Nothing like s 368(1A) was added for it: whether you were dismissed is a jurisdictional fact the Commission must decide before it can deal with the claim on its merits, and your employer can ask for that to be decided first (Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279 at [8]; Australian Hearing v Peary [2009] AIRCFB 680 at [41]).

Time limits and who can claim

  • 21 days. An unfair dismissal application must be made within 21 days after the dismissal took effect (s 394(2)(a)), and a general protections application within 21 days after the alleged dismissal took effect (s 366(1)(a)). For a forced resignation, count from the day the resignation took effect. An application lodged before then may be treated as premature, so get advice on timing if you are working out notice (Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 at [12]). A late application needs exceptional circumstances. See the 21-day rule.
  • Minimum employment period. For unfair dismissal, you need at least 6 months' service, or 12 months if your employer has fewer than 15 employees (ss 23, 383).
  • Award, agreement or income. For unfair dismissal, a modern award or enterprise agreement must cover you, or your earnings must be under the high income threshold (s 382(b)).

Before you resign: practical steps

  1. Raise it in writing first. Put the problem to your employer, and use any grievance process. Options you did not try can weigh against you (Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279 at [24], [29]).
  2. Keep records. Payslips, emails, texts and dated notes of conversations.
  3. Consider telling your employer about a health condition that affects you at work. The test looks at your circumstances as far as your employer knew them (Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 at [55]).
  4. Get advice before you resign. A resignation is hard to undo, and leaving usually ends any chance of a stop-bullying order (see workplace bullying).
  5. Do not resign in anger or as leverage. A resignation given in protest is still a resignation (Godwell v Wiliams [2025] WAIRC 00376 at [88], a WA decision). If you have resigned in distress and did not mean it, say so in writing promptly (Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson [2026] FWCFB 82 at [66]).
  6. Give your real reasons when you resign. Set out, factually, the conduct that left you no choice. In Ryan v ISS Integrated Facility Services Pty Ltd [2014] FWCFB 8451, a letter calling it a "forced resignation" did not stop a finding that it was voluntary (at [3], [6]), but your letter still records what happened.
  7. Diarise the deadline. Count 21 days after the day the resignation takes effect, and lodge in time.

If you work in Western Australia

  • The claim. In the WA state system an employee can claim they were "harshly, oppressively or unfairly dismissed" (s 29(1)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA)). The referral must be made within 28 days after the employment ends (s 29(2)(a)), unless the WA Industrial Relations Commission accepts it late because it would be unfair not to (s 29(3)).
  • The same approach to resignations. In Fedec v Minister for Corrective Services [2017] WAIRC 00828, a WA Full Bench (deciding an industrial agreement claim) said a tribunal can look behind a resignation, and described its approach as consistent with O'Meara v Stanley Works Pty Ltd [2006] AIRC 496 (at [30], [32], [35]).
  • Other options decide many cases. In Godwell v Wiliams [2025] WAIRC 00376, an employee resigned after a dispute over his duties and hours. Resigning was not his only recourse: he could have sought advice, gone to his union or a regulator, or used the dispute procedure (at [74], [80]-[81]).

See unfair dismissal in WA for which system you are in and how a WA claim runs.

What to do now

Still have questions?

Three ways to talk to us. Free discussion, no obligation.

Start AI chat1300 967 552