Home Learn Unfair Dismissal

Serious misconduct and summary dismissal: can you be sacked on the spot?

Serious misconduct is conduct so serious that your employer can end your employment straight away, without notice. Ending the employment that way is called summary dismissal, or instant dismissal. Yes, an employer can sack you on the spot. Whether it was entitled to, and whether the dismissal was fair, are separate questions. This page covers what counts as serious misconduct, what you lose and keep, and how the Fair Work Commission looks at the label.

If you were walked out today, two things matter more than anything else on this page: you generally have 21 days to bring a claim, and the word your employer used in the letter does not decide whether the dismissal was fair.

Short answers

Can I be sacked on the spot?

An employer can end your employment immediately. For most permanent employees, doing it without notice or pay in lieu of notice is lawful only if the reason really was serious misconduct. If it was not, you are owed your notice, and you may also have an unfair dismissal or general protections claim.

What is serious misconduct?

Conduct serious enough to justify ending the employment without notice, such as theft, fraud, assault or sexual harassment. The full list of examples is below.

Do I still get paid notice?

Not if your employment was ended because of serious misconduct. If your employer gets that wrong, the notice is still owed.

What am I still owed?

Under the Fair Work Act: your wages for work already done, all your untaken annual leave, and any long service leave you have already become entitled to. WA state-system employees can lose some annual leave (see the WA section below).

I was dismissed for serious misconduct with no notice. Can I challenge it?

You can, if you are eligible to bring an unfair dismissal claim. The Commission decides for itself whether the conduct happened, whether it was a valid reason, and whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The one exception is a small business employer that followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (see below).

The allegations are untrue. Does that make the dismissal unfair?

Usually. If the conduct did not happen, there is no valid reason, and "the absence of a valid reason will almost invariably render the termination unfair" (Parmalat Food Products Pty Ltd v Wililo [2011] FWAFB 1166 at [24]). In practice the employer has to call the evidence that proves the misconduct it relies on (NSW Trains v Al-Buseri [2023] FWCFB 165 at [22]). Again, a small business that followed the Code is judged differently.

What counts as serious misconduct

The Fair Work Act says serious misconduct has the meaning given by the regulations. Regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) says it has its ordinary meaning, and then gives examples.

  • Serious misconduct includes:
    1. wilful or deliberate behaviour that is inconsistent with the continuation of the employment contract (reg 1.07(2)(a));
    2. conduct that causes a serious and imminent risk to the health or safety of a person, or to the reputation, viability or profitability of the employer's business (reg 1.07(2)(b));
    3. theft, fraud, assault or sexual harassment in the course of your employment (reg 1.07(2)(c));
    4. being intoxicated at work (reg 1.07(2)(d)); and
    5. refusing to carry out a lawful and reasonable instruction that is consistent with your employment contract (reg 1.07(2)(e)).

The last three come with an exception. They do not count if you can show that, in the circumstances, your conduct did not make it unreasonable to keep you on during the notice period (reg 1.07(3)). For those three, the burden of showing that is on you.

The list says "includes", so it is not closed. Conduct that is not on it can still be serious misconduct in its ordinary meaning, and conduct that is on it can still fall short in a particular case.

Misconduct and serious misconduct are not the same

Plenty of conduct is misconduct without being serious misconduct: lateness, a rude email, a breach of a minor policy. Ordinary misconduct may justify a warning, or sometimes dismissal with notice. For employees covered by the notice rules, only serious misconduct allows dismissal without notice.

The difference matters less in an unfair dismissal claim than people expect. An employer does not have to prove misconduct serious enough to justify summary dismissal to show it had a valid reason, although proven serious misconduct will be enough (Sharp v BCS Infrastructure Support Pty Ltd [2015] FWCFB 1033 at [32]).

Instant dismissal with pay in lieu is different

If you were told to leave immediately but paid for your notice period, that is not summary dismissal in the legal sense. You were dismissed with payment in lieu of notice.

What you lose, and what you keep

Notice

Normally your employer must give you written notice of your last day, and a minimum period of notice or payment in lieu (s 117 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)). The notice rules in the National Employment Standards, and the redundancy pay rules, do not apply to:

  • "an employee whose employment is terminated because of serious misconduct" (s 123(1)(b));
  • an employee engaged for a specified period, task or season (s 123(1)(a)); or
  • a casual employee (s 123(1)(c)).

The serious misconduct words look at why your employment actually ended. If your employer says serious misconduct but the conduct did not happen, or was not serious misconduct, the exclusion does not apply and the notice is owed. Unpaid notice can be recovered like any other underpayment. See underpayment.

Your employment contract may also give you a notice period. At common law, an employer can end the contract without notice only for a serious breach, and a Victorian Supreme Court judge has said that summary dismissal places "a heavy burden on the employer to justify dismissal without notice" (Rankin v Marine Power International Pty Ltd [2001] VSC 150 at [250]). Where the contract gives more notice than the Act, a claim for it is a contract dispute.

Annual leave

Under the Fair Work Act, if you have untaken annual leave when your employment ends, your employer must pay it out (s 90(2)). There is no exception for serious misconduct. Your employer cannot hold it back as a bargaining chip, or count it as something extra in a settlement. The WA state system is different: see below.

Long service leave

Long service leave comes mostly from state and territory laws, and they differ on what happens when you are dismissed for serious misconduct. Under the Long Service Leave Act 1958 (WA), an employee with 7 or more years of service is generally paid a proportionate amount of long service leave on leaving. That pro rata payment is lost if the employer ends the employment for serious misconduct, but leave you had already become entitled to is not (s 8(2)(c), (3)). Elsewhere, check your state or territory's law and any award or agreement that covers you.

Why the label does not decide whether it was fair

If you are eligible to bring an unfair dismissal claim (generally 6 months' service, or 12 months with a small business, and cover by an award or enterprise agreement or income under the high income threshold), the Commission asks whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The unfair dismissal checklist walks through who can claim. Four points matter most in a serious misconduct case.

1. Serious misconduct is not the test

A Full Bench has said that serious misconduct as defined in regulation 1.07 "is not the criterion for whether a valid reason exists ... or for whether a dismissal is unfair or not", although conduct of the kinds listed may well be a valid reason (O'Connell v Wesfarmers Kleenheat Gas Pty Ltd [2015] FWCFB 8205 at [23]).

2. The Commission decides whether the conduct happened

Where the conduct is disputed, the Commission must decide whether it took place and what it involved, on the evidence before the Commission. The test is not whether your employer believed, on reasonable grounds, that you did it (King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd [2000] AIRC 1019 at [23]-[24]).

The standard is the balance of probabilities, but serious allegations need stronger evidence. In a theft case, a Full Bench said that reasonable satisfaction "should not be produced by inexact proofs, indefinite testimony, or indirect inferences", the words of Dixon J in Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34 (Coogee Legion Ex-Service Club Ltd v Giblin [2024] FWCFB 270 at [55]-[57]). It also said an employer does not have to prove theft beyond reasonable doubt before alleging it (at [61]).

3. A valid reason does not make the dismissal fair

It is "a bedrock principle" that a dismissal can be harsh, unjust or unreasonable even though there was a valid reason for it (Appeal by B, C and D [2013] FWCFB 6191 at [41]). The Commission weighs everything else too, including:

  • whether you were told the reason and given a chance to respond before the decision (see how to respond to a show cause letter);
  • your length of service and your record;
  • how others were treated for the same conduct; and
  • whether dismissal was out of proportion to what you did.

In Sydney Trains v Hilder [2020] FWCFB 1373, a positive drug test in breach of policy was a valid reason (at [35]), yet the finding that the dismissal was harsh, and the order reinstating the employee, stood because of factors in his favour (at [1], [41]-[42]).

4. Misconduct can reduce the compensation

If the Commission is satisfied that your misconduct contributed to the decision to dismiss you, it must reduce any compensation by an appropriate amount (s 392(3)).

If your employer is a small business

A small business employer (fewer than 15 employees, counting regular casuals and associated entities) that follows the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code has not unfairly dismissed you (ss 385(c), 388). The Code says it is fair to dismiss without notice or warning "when the employer believes on reasonable grounds that the employee's conduct is sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal".

The Commission then asks whether, at the time, your employer actually held that belief, and whether it rested on reasonable grounds, which includes a reasonable investigation. It does not decide whether the employer was right (Pinawin v Domingo [2012] FWAFB 1359 at [29]). Only an employer that can rely on the Code may fall back on a reasonable belief; every other employer has to prove the conduct (Coogee Legion Ex-Service Club Ltd v Giblin [2024] FWCFB 270 at [55]).

The Code answers only the unfair dismissal question. If the misconduct did not happen, your notice is still owed, however reasonable your employer's belief.

If the real reason was something else

  • An employer must not dismiss you because you made a complaint or exercised another workplace right, because of a protected attribute, or because of a temporary absence through illness or injury. Calling it serious misconduct does not prevent that claim.
  • Once you allege a prohibited reason, the employer has to prove it was not the reason (s 361).
  • You generally have to choose between this claim and an unfair dismissal claim.

See general protections and Sacked for speaking up.

Serious misconduct examples from real cases

Each of these turned on its own facts, so read them as illustrations, not rules.

Theft

A duty manager at a club was summarily dismissed for theft after CCTV showed she received a drink at the bar without paying, the day staff were told to pay for everything they consumed. The Commission found she had not deliberately taken the drink, so the alleged misconduct did not occur, and a Full Bench upheld the finding that there was no valid reason (Coogee Legion Ex-Service Club Ltd v Giblin [2024] FWCFB 270 at [5]-[11], [63]).

Violence and fighting

A long-serving umpires' coach grabbed a member of the public's shirt and pushed him about 40 metres towards the gate of a closed oval, after the man grabbed his shoulder. The dismissal was found not to be unfair, and a Full Bench dismissed his appeal (Kalayzich v Australian Football League [2026] FWCFB 190 at [5]-[6], [93]).

The Full Bench said the circumstances of a physical altercation must be looked at in deciding whether there was a valid reason. An employee who starts a fight without provocation and stays the aggressor clearly gives one; one who only stops the other person from injuring them is unlikely to (at [75]).

Sexual harassment

A senior academic, then acting dean of a faculty, was summarily dismissed for sexually harassing a colleague who reported directly to him. The Full Bench upheld the finding of sexual harassment and said the harasser's intention is irrelevant (University of Melbourne v Owczarek [2026] FWCFB 230 at [1], [99]).

Even so, the finding that the dismissal was unfair, and his reinstatement, stood. That rested on the employer's earlier informal handling of the conduct and its delay in acting, weighed under s 387(h) (at [112], [120], [162]-[163]). The Full Bench warned that this was not vindication (at [153]).

Out-of-hours conduct

Conduct outside work can justify dismissal only in limited circumstances (Rose v Telstra Corporation Ltd [1998] AIRC 1592):

  • where, viewed objectively, it is likely to cause serious damage to the employment relationship;
  • where it damages the employer's interests; or
  • where it is incompatible with your duty as an employee.

In essence it must be so serious as to indicate a rejection of the employment contract. The current Full Bench statement of the test is Ventia Australia Pty Ltd v Pelly [2023] FWCFB 201 at [93]-[101]: the conduct must be sufficiently connected to the employment, and without that connection it is not a valid reason. Employees privately sharing offensive material in a Facebook group was not, by itself, enough (at [123]-[125]).

Social media

A truck driver dismissed for offensive Facebook posts about two managers was reinstated, and a Full Bench dismissed the employer's appeal (Linfox Australia Pty Ltd v Stutsel [2012] FWAFB 7097 at [43]). But it warned that employees "should therefore exercise considerable care", because posts reach more people than pub talk and leave a permanent record (at [26]).

What to do if you are accused or dismissed

  1. If you are still employed and facing allegations, respond in writing, allegation by allegation, before the deadline. See how to respond to a show cause letter.
  2. If you have been dismissed, note the date the dismissal took effect: an unfair dismissal or general protections claim must be made within 21 days after it. Do not wait for an internal appeal or a negotiation to finish. See the 21-day time limit.
  3. Keep the termination letter and save your evidence now: messages, rosters, the names of witnesses, and your notes of each meeting.
  4. Check your final pay: wages, annual leave, accrued long service leave, and notice if the serious misconduct label is wrong.
  5. Do not sign a deed of release or a resignation letter on the spot. See settlement deed review.

For the claim itself, start at unfair dismissal.

In the WA state system

Most employees in Western Australia are in the national system and everything above applies. If you work for a sole trader, a partnership or another unincorporated employer, or for most of the WA public sector or local government, you are in the WA state system. There:

  • an unfair dismissal claim is a claim that you were harshly, oppressively or unfairly dismissed (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 29(1)(c)), and it must be referred to the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission no later than 28 days after the day your employment ended (s 29(2)(a));
  • there is no Small Business Fair Dismissal Code;
  • if you were dismissed without the notice your contract required, that can be a separate claim for a denied contractual benefit (s 29(1)(d)); notice under a WA award is not claimed that way (see underpayment in WA); and
  • untaken annual leave for a part-completed year of service is not paid out if you were dismissed for your own fault, and leave for any year of service completed after the misconduct is not paid out if you were dismissed for misconduct (Minimum Conditions of Employment Act 1993 (WA) s 26(2)(b), (3)).

See unfair dismissal in WA and contractual benefits in WA.

Still have questions?

Three ways to talk to us. Free discussion, no obligation.

Start AI chat1300 967 552